Sign up here |
|
|---|

Why Was Marketecture Live Half Empty? And Why That's Actually the Most Interesting Story in Ad Tech Right Now.
Let me tell you about a conference that happened this week in New York City.
It was supposed to have a thousand people. It had dozens.
Marketecture Live. March 10th and 11th. The Glasshouse, which is a genuinely beautiful venue on the west side of Manhattan, the kind of place that looks incredible in the promotional photos and even better in person. Two days. A curated agenda. Sponsored breakfasts. A Russ & Daughters pop-up station, because nothing says "we're serious about ad tech" like hand-sliced lox at 8am.
And according to multiple people who were actually there, people I trust, people with no particular axe to grind, the rooms were dark.
The corners were empty. The "1,000+ Attendees" that lived on the registration page was, to put it charitably, aspirational.
Now. I know what some of you are thinking. You've been sliding into my inbox for months asking me to go after Ari Paparo. You've been waiting. You've been patient. You've sent me the links. You've forwarded me the LinkedIn posts.
That's not what this is.
I'm going to say something that might surprise you: consider this column an advertisement for Marketecture Live. Genuinely. If you are in ad tech and you are not going to this event, you should reconsider. You should go if for no other reason than to show your face, shake some hands, and be in the room where the conversations are actually happening. So to everyone who has been hoping I'd unload on Ari: sorry to disappoint.
Ari Paparo is good at what he does. Marketecture, the podcast, the newsletter, the whole media operation, is genuinely one of the sharper things in this industry. He built something real. David Murnick, who attended and spoke with a number of people there, put it plainly: "The conversations I had were just okay, but the few dozen that were great, were genuinely great." That's not nothing. In an industry drowning in content that says a lot and means very little, a few dozen genuinely great conversations is worth the trip.
He didn't invite me. He probably never will. I've made my peace with that. I have my theories about why. But I'm not in the business of relitigating personal grievances in public. Let's move on.
This column is about everything around Ari that the industry built, and that the industry is now, slowly and somewhat dramatically, rejecting.
First, Let's Talk About Conference Fatigue. Because Oh My Gd.
The ad tech and martech conference calendar has become a form of psychological endurance testing.
In the last thirty days alone, thirty days, one month, the same amount of time it takes to finish a Netflix series you're not even sure you like, there have been a half-dozen major industry events. Same city or close to it. Same audience. Same panels. Same people. Sometimes, I am not exaggerating here, free events happening literally down the block at the exact same time.
ADCP, the agentic advertising protocol, which is actually one of the genuinely interesting technical developments in this space right now, held several informal gatherings around the same period. No ticket price. No sponsor wall. No lanyard. Just people who cared about the thing showing up to talk about the thing.
Those gatherings, by multiple accounts, drew more people than some of the paid conferences happening nearby.
Read that again.
The free, informal, no-frills gatherings about a real technical standard drew more bodies than the produced, sponsored, professionally catered events with the nice venue and the Momofuku pop-up lunch station.
That is information. That is the market speaking.
And then there's RampUp, bless their hearts, who made the very generous and very strategically savvy decision to pay for their clients to attend their event. Great for RampUp. Great for their clients. Genuinely problematic for every other event happening in the same window, because those clients, the brand and agency people that every conference in existence is desperately trying to attract, arrived in New York City already exhausted, already fed, already conferenced within an inch of their professional lives.
You cannot ask people to run a marathon and then act surprised when they don't want to go for a jog the next morning. That's not how humans work. That's not how any of this works.
The Speaker-Investor-Owner Industrial Complex
Okay. Here is where I need you to put down your coffee, because I'm going to say something that is going to sound obvious once I say it, and yet somehow never gets said out loud in polite company.
At a significant number of industry conferences, many of the speakers are also investors or owners of the event.
Terry Kawaja spoke at Marketecture Live. Terry Kawaja is also an owner and investor of Marketecture Live. Of course he spoke. That's the deal. You put money in, you get a microphone. That's not a secret. Nobody's pretending otherwise.
But here's the thing. When you look at the speaker roster and a meaningful percentage of those names are people who have a financial stake in the event they're standing on stage at, you have not created a conference. You have created a very expensively produced sales meeting with better lighting.
The audience, the people who paid for tickets, or who took two days away from their actual jobs to be there, becomes the captive market. The "content" becomes the pitch. The "panel discussion" becomes the product demo with better moderation.
This is not evil. This is not some shadowy conspiracy. It is the entirely predictable result of a business model that incentivizes exactly this behavior. You build the event. You bring your network. Your network speaks. Your network sells. Everyone goes home with a badge photo for LinkedIn.
But audiences are catching on. They are doing the math. They are looking at the agenda and asking themselves, honestly, before they book the flight and the hotel and take the meetings, "am I going to learn something here, or am I going to be sold to for eight hours while standing on concrete floors eating passed appetizers?"
And increasingly, the answer they're arriving at is: I can be sold to from my couch. For free. Without the travel.
Let's Talk About the Women Who Aren't In the Room.
I've been sitting with this section the longest. Because it's the most important and also the easiest to dismiss, and I refuse to let it be dismissed.
Women are making deliberate, coordinated decisions not to attend industry events that do not have explicit, published, enforced harassment policies.
Not as a protest. Not as a Twitter campaign. Not as a political statement. As a basic, rational, entirely reasonable assessment of their own safety and comfort based on years of accumulated experience in rooms that failed them.
I was told, by more than one person, through more than one channel, that people attending Marketecture Live approached the organizers and asked about a harassment policy. I cannot independently verify the exact details of that exchange. I am not making a specific, sourced accusation against this specific event. I want to be scrupulously clear about that.
But I am saying: if you can't answer that question clearly, publicly, and in writing before the event, you are making a choice about who gets to feel safe in your room. And the people you're excluding are noticing.
Sexual harassment at ad tech events is not a rumor. It is not a niche concern raised by people who have nothing better to do. It is a documented, persistent, industry-wide problem that has driven talented, brilliant, indispensable women out of meetings, out of companies, out of career tracks, and in too many cases out of the industry entirely.
I have written about this. I keep writing about it. I will keep writing about it until I am boring even myself, because it keeps happening.
Here is what has changed, though, and this is actually important: women have stopped just leaving quietly.
They are now, collectively and increasingly, making the decision before they arrive. They are asking, before they register, before they book the hotel, before they take the train in and put on the uncomfortable shoes, does this event have a policy? Is there someone I can report to? What actually happens if something goes wrong?
If your event cannot answer those questions in writing, on your website, before the first session, some of the most valuable people in your industry will simply not come. And they will tell their networks. And their networks will tell their networks. And you will look out at your beautiful venue with the lox station and the Momofuku lunch and wonder why the rooms feel thin.
The empty seats have a cause. This is part of it.
The Deeper Disease: Tech Bro Conference Culture and the Performance of Importance
But zoom out further. Way further. Because there's something even bigger happening here that a single event's attendance numbers can't fully capture.
The ad tech and martech industry has been running a very specific performance for a very long time. And people, smart people, busy people, people with actual things to do, are exhausted by it.
The performance goes like this:
Gather the same hundred and fifty people. Put them in a room with good AV. Have them tell each other how transformative everything is. Reference the same five trends. Namecheck the same platforms. Say "the open web" and "signal loss" and "agentic" and "outcomes" with great conviction. Issue a press release. Post the photo with the panel. Repeat in six weeks at a different venue with a slightly different title.
That's it. That's the whole show.
And look, I'm not naive. I understand why this happens. The economics of B2B media events are genuinely brutal. Sponsors need ROI. Organizers need to pay for the venue and the catering and the AV crew. Speakers want platforms. It's a system. It more or less works. Or it did.
What it has never been is honest.
It has never been honest about the fact that the "exclusive" event has a thousand people on the waitlist because scarcity is manufactured. It has never been honest about the fact that the panelists were selected partly because of who they write checks to. It has never been honest about attendance numbers, about the gap between the aspirational marketing and the actual room.
And increasingly, the audience, which is made up of some of the sharpest marketing and technology minds in the world, is done pretending not to notice.
These are people who spend their professional lives measuring things. Attribution. Lift. Incrementality. Conversion. They know what a real number looks like. They know what a fake one smells like. And when the registration page says a thousand and the room has dozens, they file that information away. They share it with colleagues. They remember it next time the invite arrives.
So Go. Seriously. Go.
Here's where I'm supposed to offer ten bullet points and a cautionary conclusion. That's the format. That's what you do.
Instead I'm going to end with something that might genuinely surprise you.
Go to Marketecture Live. Next year, whenever it is. Put it on your calendar now.
I mean that. Not sarcastically, not with an asterisk. The conversations that are worth having in this industry are happening in rooms like this one. David Murnick said it better than I could: the great conversations were genuinely great. In a world where most conferences give you ninety minutes of recycled slide decks and a lukewarm chicken lunch, genuinely great conversations are a rare and valuable thing.
Ari built something worth attending. The programming is honest. The people who show up, the ones who actually show up, are there because they want to engage, not just because their company bought a table. That self-selection matters more than headcount.
The industry needs Marketecture Live to succeed. It needs events that prioritize substance over spectacle, that attract real practitioners, that create space for the kind of frank conversation that doesn't happen on a stage with a sponsor banner behind it.
What it doesn't need is for those events to overpromise on attendance, go silent on harassment policy, and participate in a conference calendar so overcrowded that even the best events get lost in the noise.
Fix those things, and the rooms won't be dark.
The lox will be waiting. Show up.

The Rabbi of ROAS

