Look, you could spend your week reading the same breathless press releases about how AI is going to revolutionize advertising, attend a webinar where a vendor explains why their particular flavor of snake oil is actually a sophisticated measurement solution, and nod politely at a conference panel where four people who work for companies with competing interests all somehow agree on everything.
Pesach Lattin, the industry's most reliably unpolite interviewer, spent the last few days dragging three people who have genuinely built things — not just talked about building things — in front of a microphone and refusing to let them off easy. The result was less a podcast and more an intervention for an entire industry that has been confidently measuring the wrong things, building on infrastructure it never actually owned, and calling a drawer full of broken tools a "tech stack" for going on two decades now.
Matt Spiegel, who founded Resolution Media at 25, sold it to Omnicom, helped launch one of the first programmatic trading desks, and now leads identity strategy at TransUnion, showed up to deliver the kind of Season 8 premiere that makes you want to flip a table. His central thesis: AI is not the solution to your performance problems. It is an amplifier of everything already broken underneath. If your data is siloed, incomplete, or wrong — and statistically speaking, yours probably is — AI doesn't fix it. It exposes it. Loudly. To everyone. He also noted, with the calm of a man who has seen too much, that 62% of marketers are confidently measuring the wrong things entirely. Which means the other 38% are either lying or very, very lucky.
Jeremy Hlavacek, who built one of the first programmatic publisher operations at The Weather Company, ran revenue strategy at IBM Watson Advertising, and led identity and data work at Experian before anyone was calling it "identity and data work," came in with a slightly different angle and arrived at roughly the same destination. The open web is structurally degrading. The cookie was never designed for identity — it was free, accidental infrastructure that an entire industry built its house on because it was there and nobody charged for it. The deterministic versus probabilistic debate that has consumed approximately ten thousand conference panels is, in his view, the wrong question entirely. And his ten-year-old son thinks the internet is for old people, which Jeremy suspects might be the most honest market research the industry has produced in years.
Justin Pearse, co-founder of New Digital Age and BlueStrike Group, brought thirty years of watching this industry nearly die and somehow not die to the conversation, and the perspective is genuinely unlike anything you will get from someone who has only been around for one or two cycles. The AI panic, he argues, has already peaked — which tells you more about how the industry processes fear than it does about AI itself. Attention metrics are going off the boil. Retail media is the closest thing to honest attribution anyone has ever produced. And the advertising industry, for all its dysfunction, has an almost supernatural ability to survive everything that should kill it — not because it fixes its problems, but because it is extraordinarily talented at deferring them until they become someone else's problem.
Three episodes. One consistent verdict. The industry is resilient, innovative, frequently brilliant, and absolutely world-class at kicking cans down roads and calling it strategy.
Spotify · Apple Podcasts · YouTube · Amazon Music · iHeart Radio · Pocket Casts · Overcast · anywhere else you hide from your inbox
Want more than the audio? Adotat+ at ADOTAT.com gets you the full written series on every guest, extended analysis, premium episodes, and the kind of industry breakdown that doesn't end with a vendor call to action. Subscribe before someone in your company does it first and pretends they found it themselves.
The ADOTAT Show is proudly sponsored by Troutman Amin LLP and Incremental.com — two organizations that, unlike most of the industry, actually know what they're measuring.
The Rabbi of ROAS