- ADOTAT Newsletter - Adtech, Marketing and Media
- Posts
- Ad Tech’s Midlife Crisis: Servers Rebel, Netflix Goes Full Walled Garden, and Oracle Babysits TikTok
Ad Tech’s Midlife Crisis: Servers Rebel, Netflix Goes Full Walled Garden, and Oracle Babysits TikTok
Browsers, Walled Gardens, and Carbon Guilt Trips—Just Another Week in the Circus
Pesach Lattin (ADOTAT)
March 21, 2025
Ah, another week in the ad tech funhouse, where the mirrors are cracked, and the clowns are running the show.
This week?
Chaos reigns, as always.
🚨 The IAB Tech Lab has officially rage-quit browsers. After years of Chrome and Safari treating programmatic like the kid who got left off the birthday invite list, the Tech Lab’s cooked up a new “trusted server.” Translation? They’re sneaking out of the browser’s surveillance and setting up shop in the server room. It’s server-side redux—but with better branding and more PowerPoints. Bold move or just another reshuffling of the same deck chairs on the Titanic? Jury’s out, but don’t expect Google to lose sleep.
🚨 Netflix went full Regina George this week, rolling out its NAS Stack and telling the entire CTV industry: “You can’t sit with us.” A walled garden wrapped in an overpriced black turtleneck, NAS promises low ad loads and high control. But if you’re looking for transparency, don’t hold your breath—Netflix is keeping pod-level data locked tighter than a Beverly Hills country club.
🚨 Meanwhile, Oracle is out here auditioning for a bad political thriller, offering a TikTok “fix” so flimsy even Washington’s finest lobbyist-fed lawmakers are calling BS. ByteDance keeps the algorithm, Oracle babysits the perimeter, and lawmakers are eye-rolling so hard it might be a health hazard.
🚨 Over in carbon guilt land, Scope3 and XR are trying to turn emissions into a KPI, which sounds noble until you remember marketers get hives at the mere thought of sacrificing scale. Expect lots of “we care about sustainability” LinkedIn posts… and then business as usual behind closed doors.
🚨 And retail media? Oh, that’s just an all-out turf war behind the scenes. CMOs, shopper teams, and media leads are brawling over who controls the budget while Retail Media Networks whisper sweet nothings into every ear and pocket the trade dollars.
In short? Another week of ad tech promising to “change everything” while duct-taping new buzzwords onto old problems.
Welcome to the industry where the only thing moving faster than your server logs is the spin cycle.
Stay bold, stay curious, and know more than you did yesterday.
🚨 The IAB Tech Lab Declares War on Browsers—Can Server-Side Save Programmatic?
🔍 The Accusation:
The IAB Tech Lab is fed up with browsers playing hall monitor, slapping publishers' knuckles every time they try to make a buck. Enter the "trusted server"—an open-source framework designed to kick programmatic ad plumbing out of the browser’s sandbox and into a shiny new server. Sounds like a jailbreak... or maybe just another way to shuffle the same deck.
📜 The Evidence:
The Tech Lab’s prototype plugs into Prebid Server, promising publishers a self-hosted playground where bidding, targeting, and measurement calls are all done server-side. Translation: fewer pixels, fewer third-party scripts, and fewer excuses. Early testers? Three mystery publishers (no names, because suspense) and Equativ, already tinkering with integrations. And the Tech Lab is dangling six figures in engineering help to lure in every ID vendor, measurement shop, and SSP that isn’t too busy navel-gazing.
⚠️ The Catch:
Sure, “moving programmatic out of the browser” sounds radical, but let’s not kid ourselves—server-side anything has been around longer than half the interns running DSPs. Plus, browser makers aren’t exactly shaking in their boots. Chrome’s Privacy Sandbox is still marching forward, and Safari is still Apple’s privacy pet project. So, will this “trusted server” really give publishers the power back, or just saddle them with new headaches, new specs, and more emails from Prebid?
🔥 The Big Question:
Is this a true power grab that rewrites the rules—or just the same tired game of “please, sir, may I have some more data”?
🎤 Industry Response:
Publishers are cautiously optimistic (read: desperate for any edge), while the buy side is eye-rolling hard. Meanwhile, browsers haven’t even blinked. They’re too busy shipping more privacy patches and throwing shade at third-party cookies from their ivory towers.
🚨 Netflix’s NAS Stack: Streaming’s New Gated Community
🔥 The Headline Grabber:
Netflix is rolling out its own full-stack ad tech—Netflix Ads Suite (NAS)—and betting it can be both the cool kid at the CTV lunch table and the hall monitor. They’re blending low ad loads with hyper-personalized targeting and no third-party ad tags. It’s basically streaming’s answer to “you can’t sit with us.”
📜 The Numbers Pitch:
Netflix is boasting about engagement that doesn’t drop even after three hours of binge-watching. Members glued to their couches = brands paying top dollar for attention. NAS plugs into DV360, The Trade Desk, and Xandr, while quietly locking down the walled garden. Meanwhile, Netflix plans to crank out custom ad formats faster than you can say "pause ad."
🎤 The Buyer Buzz:
Agencies are intrigued but side-eyeing the lack of pod-level transparency. Buyers like Netflix’s premium sheen, but it’s not lost on anyone that Amazon is racing ahead with cheaper CPMs and faster scale.
⚠️ The Kicker:
It’s YouTube, but dressed in a turtleneck and telling you it's different. Is NAS about making ad buying easier—or just flexing Netflix’s control over yet another piece of the content economy?
🔍 The Existential Crisis:
Is Netflix building the future of CTV advertising, or just repackaging the same walled-garden playbook in Stranger Things wrapping paper?
🚨 Oracle’s TikTok “Fix” Might Be Washington’s Next Punchline
🔥 The Drama:
Oracle wants to “solve” the TikTok security saga with a deal that lets ByteDance keep the keys to the algorithm—while Oracle stands at the door pretending everything’s fine. Capitol Hill isn’t buying it, and neither are privacy hawks.
📜 The Evidence:
The Foreign Adversary Controlled Applications Act demands no Chinese ownership of critical tech or influence over TikTok’s recommendation engine. Yet Oracle’s proposal keeps ByteDance in control of the algorithm, dodging the spirit (if not the letter) of the law. Even lawmakers who typically love tech lobbyists are calling foul.
🎤 The Backchannel:
Hill insiders say Oracle’s been doing the rounds, but even Rep. John Moolenaar says the math doesn’t work. ByteDance refuses to sell the algorithm, and this "trust us, we’ll babysit" proposal is already triggering bipartisan eye rolls.
⚠️ The Catch:
With an April 5 deadline looming, this looks less like a deal and more like a Band-Aid over a regulatory crater. Plus, TikTok execs are still smirking in Beijing.
🔍 The Meta Question:
Is this the compromise no one wants—or just Act I of another TikTok cliffhanger?
🚨 XR and Scope3 Want to Decarbonize Adland—Will Anyone Actually Play Along?
🎤 The Pitch:
XR and Scope3’s Agentic Media Platform are trying to make carbon emissions a real KPI in media buying. Their new integration lets brands see emissions in real-time, campaign by campaign, and promises to bring this data all the way to linear TV.
📜 The Carbon Math:
Programmatic emissions can hit 70 tons of CO2 per campaign—the carbon footprint of about seven people’s annual lives. XR’s system aims to track and reduce that number via AI-driven optimization inside media workflows. Amazon DSP’s already integrated, giving this initiative some real teeth.
⚠️ The Reality Check:
Marketers are great at talking sustainability but allergic to CPM increases. So, will they actually trade scale for fewer emissions, or just slap a “net-zero” sticker on their next pitch deck?
🔥 The Cultural Rub:
Sustainability might be a boardroom buzzword, but in practice, the industry still prioritizes performance over the planet. Will Scope3’s new tools change that, or just give ad ops teams something else to ignore during QBRs?
🔍 The Stakes:
Is this the start of a real green revolution in media buying—or just another recycled “we care” campaign with no teeth?
🚨 Retail Media’s Budget Tug-of-War—Where’s the Money Actually Coming From?
🎤 The Street Fight:
Retail Media Networks are demanding brand dollars, trade dollars, shopper dollars—basically, any dollar they can pry from marketers. But behind the scenes, CMOs and commerce leads are wrestling over who owns the RMN budget kingdom.
📜 The Trend:
By 2028, retail media could represent 25% of all U.S. media spend, and 22% of CTV spend specifically. Yet agencies like Horizon’s Night Market say brands are still pulling funds from random buckets to meet RMN commitments. The Home Depot’s Orange Apron Media is leading the charge, asking brands to shift from lower-funnel shopper dollars to splashier brand campaigns—on platforms like CTV.
⚠️ The Tension:
While RMNs pitch themselves as full-funnel darlings, marketers are grumbling about murky measurement, inflated premiums, and who-owns-what debates that would make a CFO cry.
🔥 The Power Struggle:
Are RMNs becoming unstoppable full-funnel juggernauts—or are they just raiding piggy banks across the org chart?
🔍 The Messy Truth:
Everyone agrees retail media is the future—but no one seems to know which department will foot the bill.
The Browser Cartel Just Got Served (Literally)
The IAB Tech Lab just took a swing at Chrome and Safari, and while they didn’t exactly yell “Come at me, bro,” they might as well have. Their new “trusted server” framework is a not-so-subtle message to the browser overlords: “We’re done playing by your privacy sandbox rules. We’ll be over here—in the server room—getting actual work done.”
For years, browsers have been squeezing the life out of programmatic advertising like they’re auditioning for a reboot of The Sopranos. First, they went after third-party cookies. Then came the anti-tracking crackdowns and privacy arsenals disguised as user protections. Chrome and Safari turned into digital chaperones, lurking at the back of every dance, making sure advertisers don’t get too handsy with the data.
And now? The IAB Tech Lab has had it. They’ve built a digital speakeasy—the “trusted server”—where publishers can run header bidding, targeting, measurement, and reconciliation behind the velvet curtain, out of the browser’s watchful gaze. It’s like sneaking into your own kitchen after the parents have gone to bed. No more asking Chrome for permission to drop a pixel or begging Safari not to block a tag.
Tony Katsur, the IAB Tech Lab CEO, according to AdExchanger is practically channeling Howard Beale from Network, stomping into the spotlight to tell browsers: “We’re mad as hell and we’re not going to take it anymore!” Only instead of storming the streets, Katsur is pitching an open-source alternative that publishers can plug right into Prebid Server.
It’s power to the pubs, baby. Less browser interference, fewer molasses-slow pages, and more autonomy over monetization. “Why should Chrome get to dictate how you make money?” Katsur asks, like a dad telling his kid to move out and stop paying rent to Google.
But here’s the rub: will anyone show up to this party? Sure, a few brave publishers have already RSVP’d to test the prototype, and Equativ is on board, but the real question is whether the buy side will embrace yet another “framework” when they’ve already got 14 dashboards open and a migraine coming on.
Because let’s be honest—ad tech loves a good reinvention. One day it’s “next-gen header bidding,” the next it’s “AI-powered contextual targeting,” and now it’s “server-side salvation.” But unless this trusted server actually makes it easier, faster, and—heaven forbid—more profitable, most folks are going to stick with the devil they know (even if that devil looks like a Chrome browser window and sounds like Sergey Brin).
For now, it’s a bold move. A middle finger to the browser cartel. But revolutions in ad tech tend to move slower than an ad tag on a 3G connection.
Stay bold, stay curious, and know more than you did yesterday.
🚨 Discord’s Mobile Move: Gamers Get Ads, Marketers Get Loot Boxes
🎤 The Setup:
Discord is dropping its Video Quests onto mobile, letting advertisers sling trailers, announcements, and DLC teasers to a ravenous player base—while bribing users with rewards. It’s opt-in, it’s gamified, and it’s coming this June 2025.
🔥 The Bait:
Players watch a trailer, snag an exclusive in-game goodie, and everyone walks away happy—except maybe your ad budget. Campaigns with miHoYo, Max, and Nexon Games are already racking up millions of video completions, with some pulling 85%+ completion rates (that’s "binge a trailer like it’s a Netflix doc" territory).
📜 The Playbook:
Discord’s new mobile format aims to stretch beyond just gaming brands and pull in entertainment and media buyers. Play Quests drive engagement by making players actually play or stream games, while Video Quests are all about awareness.
⚠️ The Level-Up Challenge:
Sure, gamers will click for loot. But will they actually remember your brand—or just the shiny sword they unlocked? Plus, advertisers need to tread carefully or risk turning Discord’s famously anti-corporate crowd into pitchfork-wielding villagers.
🔍 The Bigger Bet:
Is Discord building the future of community-driven, reward-based ad models—or just giving brands another slot machine to pull?
🚨 Acxiom Axes 3.5% of Staff—Blame Restructuring or Omnicom Merger Jitters?
📜 The News:
Acxiom, IPG’s data darling, is handing out pink slips to 3.5% of its workforce, hitting roles in client services, finance, and partnerships. The official line? Restructuring. The backchannel whispers? Omnicom’s acquisition of IPG may be fueling exec-level belt-tightening.
🔥 The Inside Game:
Acxiom’s leadership is pointing to “internal efficiencies” as the culprit, but insiders say Kinesso and Acxiom merging under one roof has execs quietly bracing for turf wars. Plus, the looming Omnicom-IPG merger has everyone polishing their résumés and refreshing LinkedIn.
⚠️ The Market Mood:
Data firms like Acxiom are under pressure to prove they can do more with less, even as marketers pile cash into measurement, identity, and first-party data. Meanwhile, rival data shops are circling like sharks around displaced Acxiom talent.
🎤 The Industry Shrug:
Acxiom’s headcount drop is small but symbolic. Expect more M&A tremors as holding companies wrestle over who gets to steer the data ship.
🔍 The Cliffhanger:
Is this the first domino in a broader post-merger shakeout—or just a preemptive trim before Omnicom starts swinging the axe?
Here’s what’s inside the velvet-roped, paid-only section — the sharp, unvarnished truth behind the headlines. We go deeper into Discord’s mobile ad ambitions and the retail media land grab with insights that don’t make the press releases. Expect breakdowns of internal decks, executive backchannel chatter, and sharp analyses of the structural tensions plaguing both Discord’s monetization experiment and the RMN gold rush.
Why cough up for it? Because in a world drowning in surface-level hot takes, this section is where the gloves come off. You'll get the context CMOs whisper about but don’t post on LinkedIn, plus actionable intelligence that’ll make you the smartest person in your next meeting.
