- ADOTAT Newsletter - Adtech, Marketing and Media
- Posts
- Congratulations, You’ve Been Optimized Into Oblivion
Congratulations, You’ve Been Optimized Into Oblivion
Creative? Never Heard of Her: How Adtech Forgot the One Thing That Actually Works
Pesach Lattin (ADOTAT)
January 30, 2025
ADOTAT+ EDITION
You're one of the exclusive 150 who get the PAID edition of ADOTAT. Not some random freebie email blasted out to the masses—you’re in the club. See those green dots? That’s the premium content, reserved for our ADOTAT+ readers. If you’re cruising on a free trial or enjoying a month on us, soak it in and savor just how top-shelf this really is.
This is what being in the know feels like.
Our Amazing Sponsor
Table of Contents
For the last two decades, adtech has been like a Silicon Valley bro flexing about his latest AI-powered trading algorithm—throwing billions at media buys, audience targeting, and ad servers while completely ignoring the thing that actually makes ads work: creative.
It’s like buying a Michelin-star kitchen and then microwaving frozen pizza.
And now, surprise, surprise—reality is crashing down like an autoplay video ad at full volume in a quiet café.
Somewhere along the way, marketers got addicted to optimization and forgot what they were optimizing for. They became so obsessed with ad placement, bidding wars, and data science gymnastics that they lost sight of the fact that no one, literally no one, sits around marveling at how well an ad was targeted if the creative is absolute garbage. The industry started treating creativity like an annoying cousin at Thanksgiving—something they had to invite but would rather keep stuck at the kids' table.
Instead, they poured their energy into micro-analyzing every data point imaginable, convinced that the secret sauce to engagement was buried somewhere in an algorithm. Programmatic bidding? A must. Frequency capping? Crucial. Predictive analytics? Essential. But actually making an ad that resonates with human beings? Eh, not their problem. The result? A tsunami of technically optimized, strategically placed, hyper-targeted nothingburgers—ads so soulless, so mind-numbingly bland that consumers scroll past them faster than a Terms & Conditions page.
And let’s not forget the ridiculous lengths they went to justify this mess. The industry had a gold rush moment where every new acronym—DMP, SSP, DSP, RTB—promised to revolutionize advertising. They built complex ad exchanges, tracking pixels, and machine-learning-powered audience segmentation, all under the delusion that better targeting alone would make ads more effective. Spoiler alert: it didn’t. Instead, we got the advertising equivalent of a meticulously engineered, precision-targeted paper airplane—flimsy, forgettable, and destined for the trash.
The irony? Consumers caught on before the industry did. People have become so numb to digital advertising that even when an ad is supposedly “personalized,” it still lands with all the impact of a soggy piece of toast. Retargeting ads follow people around like a needy ex. Display ads pop up with the urgency of an overzealous telemarketer. And let’s not even start on the crime against humanity that is pre-roll video ads with unskippable timers.
But here’s the real kicker: while adtech was busy optimizing itself into oblivion, the actual effectiveness of ads was tanking. According to industry reports, creative quality is the single biggest driver of ad performance—bigger than targeting, bigger than brand reputation, bigger than whatever buzzword the latest VC-funded startup is pushing. Nielsen even dropped the mic with a study showing that strong creative is responsible for 86% of a digital ad’s sales lift. Yet, despite this giant flashing neon sign pointing to “MAKE BETTER ADS,” adtech continued to bet its chips on more automation, more AI, more everything but creativity.
So now, here we are—standing in the wreckage of an industry that optimized itself into irrelevance. And the ones who are actually winning? The brands that get it. The ones investing in creative optimization, dynamic storytelling, and actually making ads that people want to watch. The rest? Well, they can keep throwing money into the black hole of programmatic advertising and wondering why no one cares.
DCO: The Savior or Just Another Buzzword?
Dynamic Creative Optimization (DCO) is being hailed as the messiah of modern advertising, the shiny new wrench to fix the rusted-out machine that is digital ads. And to be fair, it’s got some real chops. At its core, DCO is the art of making sure that people actually see an ad that speaks to them instead of being force-fed another bland, one-size-fits-all piece of corporate nonsense. It’s like an ad that actually pays attention—learning from a user’s behavior, interests, and location to swap out elements like copy, images, layouts, and CTAs in real time. That means a sneaker ad for a runner in New York might highlight durability and pavement grip, while one for someone in Los Angeles might focus on breathability and heat resistance. Theoretically, it’s a no-brainer. But the question is: will adtech finally use this tool correctly, or will it just be another overhyped acronym added to the growing graveyard of “revolutionary” ad solutions?
The promise of DCO is personalization without the creep factor. We’ve all been subjected to the nightmare of hyper-targeted ads gone wrong—like when you buy a mattress and suddenly every ad across the internet starts screaming at you about mattresses for the next six months. That’s not personalization; that’s adtech acting like an obsessive ex who just can’t take the hint. DCO, when used properly, should be less about relentless chasing and more about anticipating what a consumer actually wants to see before they start throwing their phone across the room in frustration.
The difference lies in execution. Instead of blasting the same static creative at everyone, DCO ensures that the elements of an ad (headline, images, offers) are dynamically adjusted in real time based on what the user is engaging with. So if someone is browsing travel destinations in Italy, they’re more likely to see an ad featuring a picturesque villa in Tuscany rather than a generic “Book Your Next Trip” banner. This doesn’t just improve engagement; it makes people feel like the ad is actually for them rather than just another piece of spam clogging their feed.
One of the biggest hurdles in advertising has always been scaling creative. A brand can’t realistically make a thousand variations of an ad manually—well, they could, but unless they have an unlimited budget and an army of designers, it’s not happening. This is where DCO’s real magic happens. It automates the process, swapping in different elements to ensure that creative stays fresh without losing the human touch. Think of it as a high-powered assembly line, but instead of churning out the same widget, it’s constantly adjusting based on real-world engagement and performance data.
The key to success, though, is making sure the creative doesn’t feel automated. If every version of a DCO-generated ad feels like it was pieced together by a robot playing Mad Libs, consumers are going to see right through it. The best executions of DCO use a mix of AI-driven optimization and good old-fashioned human creativity. The brands that get this balance right will see results; the ones that treat DCO like a “set it and forget it” solution will just end up adding more noise to an already cluttered digital landscape.
If used correctly, DCO isn’t just a gimmick—it’s a serious performance booster. Studies show that dynamically optimized ads routinely outperform their static counterparts in engagement, CTR, and, most importantly, conversions. When people see an ad that actually makes sense for them in that moment, they’re far more likely to click, interact, and, you know, buy something. This is particularly critical in industries like e-commerce, travel, and retail, where real-time relevance can be the difference between a purchase and a lost opportunity.
But, and this is a big but, there’s always the risk of marketers treating DCO as a magic bullet—dumping all their budget into the tech without putting in the effort to make it work properly. Just slapping a DCO tag on an ad isn’t going to suddenly make it compelling. Bad creative is still bad creative, no matter how many times it gets personalized. If an ad isn’t fundamentally engaging, no amount of real-time optimization is going to fix it. That’s why brands need to think of DCO as a tool, not a strategy.
At its best, Dynamic Creative Optimization is the evolution digital advertising desperately needed. It can turn forgettable ads into engaging experiences, eliminate waste, and make sure consumers are seeing things they actually care about. But let’s be real—adtech has a long history of screwing up good ideas by prioritizing automation over actual quality. DCO is not a get-out-of-jail-free card for bad creative. It’s a way to enhance what’s already working.
So here’s the choice: use DCO as a way to elevate storytelling, make ads that feel personal, and deliver content that’s actually worth paying attention to—or keep treating it like another checkbox in a never-ending list of adtech buzzwords. The brands that get it right will reap the benefits. The ones that don’t? Well, they’ll just keep wondering why their beautifully optimized, algorithmically perfected, AI-enhanced ads are still being ignored.
And here’s where it gets even more fun: 80% of marketers now say creative quality is the biggest driver of marketing effectiveness. Shocking, right? Turns out, people actually respond to ads that don’t suck. So why did it take the industry this long to figure out that creativity isn’t just some nice-to-have, it’s the engine that actually drives results?
Let’s talk about innovation. We’re not in 2005 anymore—static banner ads and generic video spots aren’t going to cut it. Today’s digital advertising landscape is more fragmented than ever, and consumers have the attention span of a goldfish on TikTok. If brands want to capture consumer loyalty, they need to do more than just personalize ads—they need to make them interesting.
Enter the next wave of creative formats. Shoppable ads? They’re slashing the gap between product discovery and purchase, turning casual scrolling into instant transactions. 3D effects and Augmented Reality (AR)? They’re making ads immersive and interactive instead of just another forgettable distraction. Gamification? It’s finally making ads fun rather than an interruption.
Imagine an ad that doesn’t just throw a product in your face but actually tells a story—one that you can interact with, explore, and even play with. Picture an ad that dynamically changes based on the user’s location, preferences, and behavior. Now, stop imagining, because that’s already happening. Brands that embrace this shift are seeing their engagement rates skyrocket, while the ones still clinging to the old-school programmatic playbook are watching their relevance evaporate faster than third-party cookies.
Here’s the harsh truth: Marketers have spent the better part of two decades treating creative like a side salad—optional, forgettable, and only there to make the main course (aka their precious targeting and bidding strategies) look better. But here’s the kicker: consumers don’t care how efficiently an ad was served to them if it’s boring, generic, or—worst of all—completely irrelevant. AI and new creative formats are finally yanking the industry out of its self-imposed data coma, proving once and for all that no amount of targeting wizardry can save a bad ad. Data doesn’t sell products. Storytelling does.
So what’s it going to be? Keep pumping out the same dull, over-targeted slop and hope people miraculously stop ignoring it? Or finally wake up and realize that ads should do more than just exist—they should actually matter. The brands that get this will thrive because they understand that data and technology aren’t meant to replace creativity; they’re supposed to enhance it. The ones still clinging to their programmatic spreadsheets like a security blanket? Well, they’ll just keep watching their engagement rates circle the drain while wondering why consumers don’t care.
And let’s not pretend this shift is optional. Consumers have never had more control over what they watch, engage with, or completely ignore. They can block, skip, mute, and scroll past ads faster than you can say “attribution modeling.” If your creative doesn’t grab them immediately—and actually give them a reason to care—you’re already dead in the water. AI-driven optimization can tweak ad components all day long, but if the core idea is weak, you’re just shuffling deck chairs on the Titanic.
This isn’t a revolution. It’s a long-overdue correction. Marketers need to remember that advertising is supposed to engage people, not just follow them around the internet like a desperate stalker. If your entire strategy is built around hyper-targeting and retargeting without investing in actual compelling content, you’re not marketing—you’re just spamming with extra steps.
So here’s your choice: Innovate or become irrelevant. Step up, embrace creative-first advertising, and make something that people actually want to see—or keep flooding the internet with mindless, forgettable ads that consumers have already learned to tune out. The future of advertising is for those who understand that creativity isn’t a luxury—it’s the only thing standing between success and screaming into the void.
COMPANY PROFILE:
Vidmob: The Creative Data Powerhouse
Vidmob isn’t just another adtech startup riding the AI wave—it’s the creative intelligence engine brands didn’t realize they needed. Positioned as a creative data company, Vidmob analyzes ad creative at an unprecedented scale, dissecting everything from production styles and narrative arcs to the granular, frame-by-frame details of what makes an ad perform.
With $110 million in Series D funding led by Shamrock Capital, Vidmob is scaling to serve global brands like L’Oréal and Coca-Cola, helping them understand not just what creative works, but why. The platform ingests trillions of impressions, pulling data from all major digital ad channels while applying proprietary AI models to map creative decisions against real-world performance metrics—be it brand lift, ROI, conversion rates, or audience engagement.
The Future of Vidmob: Creative Optimization at Scale
Vidmob’s play isn’t just about understanding creative performance post-launch. It’s about transforming how creative gets made in the first place. With integrations inside editing platforms like the Adobe Creative Cloud and more to come, Vidmob lets marketers and designers pre-test creative before an ad even goes live. Think of it as real-time backtesting for creative decisions—ensuring that brands don’t waste media dollars on underperforming assets.
Beyond that, the company is leaning hard into generative AI, integrating a brand’s creative data into tools like Firefly, Titan, Stable Diffusion, and proprietary models to enhance creative output and ensure brand safety. Instead of generic AI-generated ads, Vidmob’s AI learns from performance data, ensuring that AI-generated assets align with what actually drives results.
The Optimization Engine
At its core, Vidmob is building a system that continuously learns from every impression—charging on a per-impression basis to access first-party creative data. Per asset pricing is available to score ads against brand guidelines and platform best practices. This means that whether it's a social media campaign, retail media push, or always-on display effort, marketers can make creative and media optimizations in real-time.
As CTV and retail media networks become more dominant in digital advertising, Vidmob is positioning itself to expand capabilities across emerging channels, ensuring that brands don’t just get visibility—they get results.
Vidmob isn’t just analyzing creative; it’s rewriting how brands approach advertising.
Vidmob isn’t just another adtech startup riding the AI wave—it’s the creative intelligence engine brands didn’t realize they needed. Positioned as a creative data company, Vidmob analyzes ad creative at an unprecedented scale, dissecting everything from production styles and narrative arcs to the granular, frame-by-frame details of what makes an ad perform.
With $110 million in Series D funding led by Shamrock Capital, Vidmob is scaling to serve global brands like L’Oréal and Coca-Cola, helping them understand not just what creative works, but why. The platform ingests trillions of impressions, pulling data from all major digital ad channels while applying proprietary AI models to map creative decisions against real-world performance metrics—be it brand lift, ROI, conversion rates, or audience engagement.
The Future of Vidmob: Creative Optimization at Scale
Vidmob’s play isn’t just about understanding creative performance post-launch. It’s about transforming how creative gets made in the first place. With integrations inside editing platforms like the Adobe Creative Cloud and more to come, Vidmob lets marketers and designers pre-test creative before an ad even goes live. Think of it as real-time backtesting for creative decisions—ensuring that brands don’t waste media dollars on underperforming assets.
Beyond that, the company is leaning hard into generative AI, integrating a brand’s creative data into tools like Firefly, Titan, Stable Diffusion, and proprietary models to enhance creative output and ensure brand safety. Instead of generic AI-generated ads, Vidmob’s AI learns from performance data, ensuring that AI-generated assets align with what actually drives results.
The Optimization Engine
At its core, Vidmob is building a system that continuously learns from every impression—charging on a per-impression basis to access first-party creative data. Per asset pricing is available to score ads against brand guidelines and platform best practices. This means that whether it's a social media campaign, retail media push, or always-on display effort, marketers can make creative and media optimizations in real-time.
As CTV and retail media networks become more dominant in digital advertising, Vidmob is positioning itself to expand capabilities across emerging channels, ensuring that brands don’t just get visibility—they get results.
Vidmob isn’t just analyzing creative; it’s rewriting how brands approach advertising..