GOOGLE GASLIGHTED US ALL 💻 The Cookie That Refused to Die — and the Industry Left Holding the Bill

Welcome to the privacy apocalypse... that never happened.

You can stop pretending now. The third-party cookie — that slimy little code fragment everyone swore was headed for a fiery death — is back. Not just alive, but thriving. Lounging in Chrome’s backend, sipping a Mai Tai, whispering “told you so” into the ear of every DSP that just spent millions trying to replace it.

Let’s rewind.

Back in 2019, Google took the stage like Moses parting the privacy sea. “We’re killing cookies in Chrome,” they declared, triggering a half-decade panic attack across every agency, identity startup, and analytics team on the planet. Cue the cookiepocalypse. Cue the conference keynotes. Cue the PowerPoint decks filled with words like “post-identity future” and “zero-party signal strategies.”

Now? After five years of sandbox experiments, regulatory flirtations, and enough acronym-laden whitepapers to kill a forest?

Google shrugged and said: “Actually, nah.”

🎭 This Was Never About Privacy. It Was About Power.

Let’s be brutally honest — and I mean Adland brutally honest, not Cannes-on-stage polite. Google never intended to kill the cookie. Not really. They intended to pretend they were killing it long enough to satisfy regulators, lock everyone into the Privacy Sandbox, and solidify their dominance over the ecosystem.

But then two things happened:

1. Regulators got louder — and a lot more curious about why Google was playing traffic cop and toll booth at the same time.

2. The entire adtech stack — from UID2 to RampID to half of your MarTech diagram — began having a collective identity crisis.

So what did Google do?

They blinked. They put out a chirpy little blog post written by Privacy Sandbox VP Anthony Chavez, saying they wouldn’t roll out a standalone cookie prompt after all. Instead, users can just futz around in Chrome’s settings like it’s 2008. Because that’s what real privacy looks like, right?

🔥 Let’s Talk About the Gaslight

While Google was busy playing bureaucratic charades, the rest of the industry was bleeding cash faster than an over-optimized open auction campaign.

One C-level exec at Publicis didn’t even bother sugarcoating it:
“ID5 is dead. They may as well shut down.”

And they’re not alone in that sentiment. Agencies like Canvas Worldwide were sold on a multi-ID strategy — UID2, RampID, TransUnion, and yes, ID5 — because the entire ecosystem demanded it. Now? Those investments are starting to look less like strategy and more like sunken cost cosplay.

Millions of dollars. Years of work. All vaporized.

Platforms like Havas built identity stacks so complicated they needed flowcharts just to explain them to junior planners. Now they’re quietly pivoting to saying things like “cookie-optional solutions” and “privacy-ready flexibility.” Translation: We’re rebranding this flaming dumpster as an artisanal fire pit.

💰 Google Wins. Everyone Else Pays.

Let’s be real:
Google never cared about your roadmap. They cared about not getting sued into regulatory oblivion while keeping the ad dollars flowing. By pausing the deprecation, they get the best of both worlds — appease advertisers and regulators, while dodging Apple-style fines and ATT-style backlash.

Meanwhile, the rest of the ad industry is left dazed, looking like the person who showed up to a canceled wedding still wearing the tuxedo.

And don’t get me started on the Privacy Sandbox. It was always a branding exercise disguised as infrastructure. It solved exactly zero of the problems it promised to address. And now, it’s been shoved into the corner like a broken treadmill — technically still functional, but mostly a clothes rack.

🫠 So, What Now?

If you’re still treating Google’s privacy roadmap as a compass, you’re in the middle of the Bermuda Triangle with a magnet taped to your face.

Here’s your reality check:

• Third-party cookies aren’t going away. Not now. Maybe not ever.

• Privacy Sandbox isn’t dead — it’s just been benched. Possibly permanently.

• ID vendors? Most will pivot, consolidate, or go poof. Some already are.

• Agencies and brands who hedged on real privacy-first strategies may get left explaining to clients why “cookieless” now means “nice-to-have.”

You didn’t just get gaslit. You got dragged through five years of compliance theater, forced to build backup tech, trained teams in the new targeting gospel — only to land right back in 2019 like it was a damn time loop.

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.