🔥 The AI Kool-Aid Machine is in Full Swing (and the Hangover Will Be Brutal) 🔥

Let’s talk about ad tech’s latest addiction—AI. Not your charming, helpful AI that reminds you to reorder oat milk or finds you a passable GIF, but the bloated, buzzword-stuffed version that’s been inflated into a “full-stack, privacy-safe, cookieless, rain-making, unicorn-riding miracle.” 🦄✨ 

If you ask any DSP or SSP exec (and you don’t even have to—they’ll volunteer it mid-latte), AI is supposedly the savior of everything broken in media buying.

Spoiler alert: it’s not.

What we’re witnessing is a full-on AI frat party. 🍹 Kool-Aid pitchers everywhere, and the entire industry is double-fisting like it’s the open bar at CES, all while promising ads that are “smarter, faster, more ethical” — meanwhile, half the programmatic supply chain is still lit up like a tire fire in a landfill of MFA sludge 🔥🗑️.

Rishad Tabaccawala, the OG agency oracle who’s been dismantling ad-world nonsense since you were still loading banner ads over dial-up, cuts straight through it:
“AI itself is not a differentiator,” he says. “You don’t have better AI than I do—I pay $20 a month for it.” 🎯

And yet, here we are, deep in a marketing landscape drunk on the fantasy of AI differentiation. Companies are slapping “AI-powered” on products like it’s duct tape, covering up the fact that behind the curtain, it’s just basic automation or glorified Excel macros. 🧯 That rules-based bidding system you’ve been using since 2017? Congrats, it’s now magically become “machine learning.” 🙄

The Trade Desk’s Kokai? It’s the poster child for this mess. 🚨 Touted as the second coming of media buying, Kokai landed with all the grace of a brick through a windshield. 🧱🪟 Instead of the sleek AI co-pilot we were promised, we got a periodic table-themed UI so confusing it makes setting up IKEA furniture look like child’s play. 🪑

One media buyer summed it up beautifully:
“It’s like piloting a rocket ship using hieroglyphics.” 🚀🔤

Meanwhile, Wesley ter Haar, founder of .Monks, openly wonders why agencies are still clinging to AI as a solution rather than seeing the fundamental shifts taking place. “AI is commoditizing creativity overnight,” he notes, meaning agencies can no longer hide behind inflated creative production budgets and buzzwords to justify their existence. “Your clients don’t need you to ‘manage’ AI,” Wesley argues, “they need you to fundamentally rethink your value. Otherwise, they’re doing it themselves.”

And speaking of doing it themselves, there’s Google’s Performance Max—the cult leader of AI ad platforms. 🕯️🤖 It’s got “trust the algorithm” energy so strong, you half expect them to hand you a Kool-Aid-branded jumpsuit. Want to know why your CPC suddenly exploded? Too bad. The Algorithm™ works in mysterious ways. 🌀 As Wesley points out with his characteristic wryness: “Everyone says ‘trust the AI,’ but nobody wants to admit they have no clue how it actually works.”

Meanwhile, marketers are throwing their budgets at AI-labeled tools while still having interns manually pause underperforming ads at midnight. 🧑‍💻☕ Your “autonomous optimization” system? Yeah, it’s quietly being micromanaged by Becky from the media team—who, by the way, has three spreadsheets open and Slack notifications blowing up. 📊💥

Tabaccawala doubles down here, shaking his head at an industry blind to reality:
“It’s like newspapers discovering digital and using it to make their trucks faster and printing presses quicker. That’s not what this is about. It’s about existential risk. It’s about fundamentally reimagining the business.”

Yet, AI-washing continues at breakneck speed. 🧼

The FTC is sharpening its knives. 🔪 The SEC is sending love letters to legal teams. 💌 There’s even a class-action lawsuit against The Trade Desk over Kokai, alleging they misled investors about how magical this new “AI-powered” platform really is. ⚖️

But despite these warnings, marketers and vendors alike keep drowning in the AI Kool-Aid 🍹 while the same old problems persist:

❌ Ads still flooding MFA wastelands.
❌ Campaigns still burning budgets on click farms.
❌ Buyers still playing whack-a-mole with performance issues.

It’s like selling someone a self-driving Tesla that’s powered by a hamster wheel. 🐹🚗 And the hamster’s on a union break.

Here’s the uncomfortable truth that Wesley and Rishad both underline: AI will reshape this industry—but first, it’s going to bulldoze some sacred cows along the way. 🐄💥 The fantasy that every DSP or agency gets to survive by simply adding “AI” to their slide decks? Yeah, that’s dead on arrival. 💀

Already, media teams are rejecting Kokai’s chemistry-class-from-hell interface 🧪 and quietly moving budgets away from Performance Max because, as Tabaccawala puts it, “People want freedom, growth, and the ability to tell their story—not an opaque algorithm dictating their budgets.”

👉 Here’s your thesis, folks:
The AI Kool-Aid machine is still humming, but the industry is finally starting to sober up. Rishad and Wesley aren’t whispering—they’re yelling from the rooftops that your “AI-powered DSP” is just putting lipstick on a pig 🐷💄—a very expensive, very black-boxed pig.

As Tabaccawala warns, “You have to reimagine your company—otherwise, a thousand days from now, you won’t recognize this industry.”

So buckle up, ad tech—the AI revolution isn’t coming, it’s already here. And the hangover? It’ll be epic. 🍸⚰️🚀

Next up: Why marketers are playing hot potato 🥔 with AI tools they barely understand—and what real AI in ad tech could look like (hint: it’s not hiding on Google’s server farm).

🚨 AI in Ad Tech 2025: Miracle Worker or Marketing Mirage?

🔍 The Accusation:
AI is now touted as adtech’s unstoppable force, automating everything from media buying to creative design. But behind all the flashy promises, marketers remain wary of trusting their budgets entirely to machines.

📜 The Evidence:

• Market Explosion: The global AI market is hitting an eye-popping $500 billion by the close of 2025, with U.S. spending alone expected to reach nearly $300 billion by 2026. Adoption isn’t slowing either—83% of businesses say AI is now their top strategic priority.

• Smarter, Faster, Better: Platforms like The Trade Desk’s Kokai and Scibids dominate bidding strategies, crunching billions of data points instantly to make lightning-fast targeting decisions.

• Creative Revolution: AI tools like Clinch, VidMob, and Omneky can whip up thousands of personalized ad variations in real-time, turning traditional creative processes into instant, adaptive masterpieces.

• Privacy, Meet AI: Privacy-first solutions like federated learning and contextual targeting 2.0 are bridging the gap between personalization and user privacy, allowing marketers to stay effective without triggering consumer backlash.

• Hyper-Personalization: AI isn't just predicting behaviors—it’s actively shaping experiences in real-time. Expect dynamic ads and hyper-targeted messaging to dominate your feeds, with predictions claiming an astounding 760% lift in revenue for AI-driven segmented campaigns.

⚠️ The Catch:
Despite AI’s near-total takeover, transparency remains shaky. Marketers love the convenience but not the uncertainty—what’s really happening inside those AI-powered black boxes? Critics argue AI is mostly “glorified regression on steroids,” repackaged by adtech firms eager to keep the money flowing. Meanwhile, questions linger: Does automated mean effective, or just efficient?

🔥 The Big Question:
As AI continues reshaping advertising, can marketers strike the right balance between trusting the machines and maintaining essential human oversight—or are we just trading old inefficiencies for shiny, new complexities?

🎤 Industry Response:
The industry is bullish on AI’s potential, yet cautious. Brands crave AI’s efficiency, but skepticism remains strong—no one wants their marketing strategy fully in the hands of an algorithm they don’t fully understand.

🚨 AI Agents vs. The Ad Industry

Kate Cook: “AI agents won’t just disrupt advertising—they’ll starve it of human attention.”

Kate Cook, Founder & Principal Consultant at Era Seven Partners, just threw a grenade into the digital ad playbook.

Her bold prediction?

“By mid-2026, AI agents will fundamentally alter how brands compete for visibility.”

And she’s not hedging. Cook is calling for the collapse of the current attention economy. As AI-powered personal agents take on the heavy lifting of “retrieving and curating information” for consumers, the oxygen feeding programmatic display ads and search ads will get sucked out of the room. No more relying on passive human attention.

Instead, Cook says, “the path to consumer attention will increasingly be filtered through these AI intermediaries.”

Translation: The machines will decide which brands get airtime, not the users.

Forget chasing CTRs like a dog after a parked car. Cook says the new KPI will be “share of model.” Yep, welcome to the era where your brand’s survival depends on how often you show up inside the AI-to-human pipeline—in other words, how frequently an AI agent recommends or surfaces your message.

“Advertisers will need AdTech to help them ensure their messaging is favored by the algorithms.”

Or in plainer terms: your creative won’t just need to be good, it’ll need to be machine-friendly. The battle for the top of mind? Now it’s a battle for the top of the model.

🎯 My Take:

Cook is basically telling every CMO, “Stop acting like it’s still 2019.” Your audience isn’t just distracted—they’re going to be entirely insulated by their AI assistants. And unless you’re programming your brand for how these agents scrape, rank, and recommend, you’re out of the loop.

This isn’t personalization. It’s AI deciding which brands get past the velvet rope.

The question is, how many marketers even know where the door is?

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.