- ADOTAT Newsletter - Adtech, Marketing and Media
- Posts
- SPECIAL REPORT: 🧙♂️ The Growing Audience Alchemy Scam
SPECIAL REPORT: 🧙♂️ The Growing Audience Alchemy Scam
Turning Clicks into Cold Brew Lovers, One BS Segment at a Time

You’ve heard the hype. Now it’s time for results
After two years of siloed experiments, proofs of concept that fail to scale, and disappointing ROI, most enterprises are stuck. AI isn't transforming their organizations — it’s adding complexity, friction, and frustration.
But Writer customers are seeing a positive impact across their companies. Our end-to-end approach is delivering adoption and ROI at scale. Now, we’re applying that same platform and technology to bring agentic AI to the enterprise.
This isn’t just another hype train that doesn’t deliver. The AI you were promised is finally here — and it’s going to change the way enterprises operate.
See real agentic workflows in action, hear success stories from our beta testers, and learn how to align your IT and business teams.

🚨 The Big Lie: "Anonymous user? No problem. We’ve got AI, machine learning, and unicorn dust."
Let’s not kid ourselves.
We built this entire digital advertising ecosystem on the promise of precision. Of automation. Of programmatic as the crown jewel of efficiency—a data-driven, machine-optimized way to reach the right person at the right time with the right message.
But here’s the plot twist:
Under the hood, a whole lot of it is just digital voodoo in a lab coat. 🧪🧙♂️
Vendors are out here claiming to turn anonymous bidstream crumbs—IP addresses, timestamps, maybe a lonely pageview on a sports blog—into robust, high-value audience profiles. And they’re not even breaking a sweat as they tell you this user is a: “Sports enthusiast, age 25–34, high-income, interested in Tesla, probably drinks organic cold brew, and votes in midterms.”
All that from what? A single click on Bleacher Report?
Come on. If your cousin shared a cat video on Facebook, would you assume he's an animal rights activist with disposable income? No? Then why are we okay with this logic when it's dressed up as audience science?
🤹♀️ The Alchemy Act: Turning Crumbs Into Clout
Here’s how the trick works:
Start with bidstream residue—things like a device ID, URL, maybe a geolocation ping from six weeks ago.
Throw it into a black box labeled “AI-powered segmentation” and hope no one asks questions.
Out pops a supposedly targetable persona, ready to be sold at a premium CPM.
Except—it’s not really a persona. It’s a fantasy.
The kind your middle school friend invented when he claimed he had a Canadian girlfriend you’d never meet.
It’s inference theater.
It’s programmatic cosplay.
And it’s completely antithetical to what programmatic was supposed to be.
We didn’t build algorithms and real-time bidding so someone could randomly label a user who glanced at a sports headline as a “luxury auto intender.”
That’s not targeting. That’s astrology with a data feed.
🔥 Why You Should Be Angry — Not Just Mildly Irritated
This isn’t just a technical issue—it’s a fundamental betrayal of trust.
💸 Advertisers are flushing budgets down the DSP drain based on fabricated audience segments.
👎 Consumers are being creepily stalked by ads that are both invasive and wildly off-target.
🧼 The adtech industry is selling itself as a science, but under-delivering with smoke, mirrors, and inference spaghetti.
🚽 Trust is circling the toilet, and if we’re not careful, what’s left of programmatic credibility will go with it.
And don’t even get me started on the “verified” vendors who double down on this nonsense while pretending their secret sauce is too complex to explain. If you can’t tell me how the sausage is made, I assume it’s mostly sawdust and old shoes.

Pesach Lattin, Publisher @ ADOTAT