
Sign up here | Advertise? Comments? |
---|
Sunday Signal vs. Noise
The Set-Up
The advertising industry doesn’t just love dashboards — it’s mainlining them like Wall Street traders mainline Red Bull. Every agency, every brand, every analyst is building dashboards stacked like Russian nesting dolls of nonsense. Peel one back and instead of clarity, you get another chart, another KPI, another “insight” that sounds like it was written by ChatGPT after three martinis.
Executives trot into boardrooms clutching AI-powered slides like they’re Moses with new commandments. Only instead of “Thou shalt not steal,” the tablets say, “Consumers are craving authenticity in Q2.” Wow. Revolutionary. Next, maybe the AI will predict that people like puppies and don’t enjoy overdraft fees.
The ugly truth? Clarity doesn’t come from stacking dashboards. It comes from burning half of them. The sharpest skill in 2025 isn’t decoding the next trendy metric. It’s having the guts to say: “This chart is garbage, this KPI is theater, this dashboard is a hallucination in a suit.”
Noise, Noise Everywhere
The Catnip of Vanity Metrics
If this industry had a drug of choice, it would be vanity metrics. Impressions. Likes. Pageviews. Followers. Engagement rates. They’re the neon-colored junk food of marketing — bright, addictive, and nutritionally useless.
They light up the dopamine receptors in CMOs like a slot machine jackpot in Vegas. Ding ding ding — three million impressions! Champagne all around. But impressions are the cotton candy of advertising: they look big and fluffy, but one lick and you realize it’s just sugar air.
The reason we fall for them? They’re easy to manipulate. Anyone can goose followers with bots, buy a million cheap impressions in a sketchy exchange, or inflate “engagement” with meaningless clicks. It’s the marketing equivalent of Photoshopping abs onto your dating profile.
Agencies and the Fluff Economy
Let’s be honest: agencies have built an entire economy on fluff masquerading as insight. Those 120-slide decks where every other slide is a meaningless chart with branded colors and a made-up acronym? That’s not strategy. That’s consulting Mad Libs designed to make sure the retainer clears.
Agencies are masters of smoke and mirrors. They’ll tell you your “Share of Cultural Resonance™” is up 13%, or that your “Audience Affinity Quotient” is outperforming benchmarks. Translation: they ran some numbers through a thesaurus and printed them on glossy slides.
And now with AI? It’s worse. AI dashboards spit out corporate horoscopes like: “Your customers are leaning into purpose-driven storytelling.” No kidding. My bubbe could’ve told you that while stirring soup. But slap an AI label on it, and suddenly it’s “cutting-edge.”
Finding the Signal
The Power of Saying “This Doesn’t Matter”
The radical act of 2025 isn’t launching another AI dashboard. It’s taking a machete to the ones you already have. Stop worshipping every metric. Slice your dashboard back to three to five meaningful KPIs. Anything more is PowerPoint confetti.
The real leaders aren’t the ones memorizing every chart. They’re the ones who walk into a meeting, sweep half the slides into the trash, and say: “This matters. That doesn’t. Kill the rest.”
That’s not anti-data. That’s pro-sanity. Because when everyone else is drowning in dashboards, the only edge is the discipline to ignore most of them.
The Industry Angle
Noise Disguised as Innovation
Adland has turned noise into a subscription service. Web3 dashboards. “Attention scores” no one can define. AI mood metrics that supposedly measure consumer happiness based on scroll speed. It’s like the industry decided to swap substance for astrology and rebrand it as strategy.
And here’s the dirty secret: most of these metrics aren’t designed to help clients. They’re designed to pad billable hours. More dashboards mean more reports, more analysis cycles, more opportunities to justify why you’re paying six figures for “optimization.”
Meanwhile, the companies that actually last are the boring ones. The ones who ignore the carnival rides and quietly keep building. They know the Ferris wheel eventually collapses, and they’d rather be on solid ground than spinning in circles with cotton candy and a nosebleed.
Dashboard Overload and Data Fatigue
We’ve hit a point of dashboard fatigue so bad it should qualify as a diagnosable condition. Teams are drowning in data. Meetings dissolve into debates over whether the purple bar on slide 47 is more important than the green line on slide 63.
Dashboards without context are fortune cookies without fortunes — just crunchy shells of numbers with nothing inside.
The smartest operators I know cap dashboards at three to five metrics max. Why? Because clarity is born of scarcity. Anything beyond that isn’t insight — it’s noise in business casual.
The Trap of Vanity Metrics
Impressions: The Emperor’s New Clothes
The most overrated number in advertising. Impressions are just billboard counts in the desert. They tell you how many times an ad technically appeared, not whether anyone actually noticed. A million impressions without clicks, conversions, or lift is just digital exhaust filling up a pretty graph.
Followers, Opens, and Pageviews: Applause Meters
Social media followers. Email open rates. Pageviews. These are applause meters. Loud, fun, and impressive until you realize applause doesn’t pay rent. A brand with 100,000 followers and 100 buyers isn’t influential. It’s a high school popularity contest with an ad budget.
CTV Completion Rate: The Hostage Metric
In Connected TV, everyone brags about their 95%+ completion rates. Here’s the gag: most CTV ads are unskippable. That’s not engagement — that’s a hostage situation with a remote. People don’t finish your ad because they’re riveted; they finish it because they’re waiting for The Bear to come back on.
CTV Impression Share: Optimizing for Air
Another shiny metric: impression share. Sounds sophisticated, but it’s just a measure of how often your ad was technically “served.” No guarantee anyone was watching, no guarantee anyone cared. Optimizing for impression share is like optimizing how much oxygen your brand got in a room. Congratulations, you existed.
Household Reach: Big but Empty
Advertisers love touting household reach. But let’s be honest: CTV ads autoplay in empty rooms, or drone away on background TVs while no one is watching. Counting “unique households” without frequency or engagement context is just another way of saying “we shouted into the void, and the void was technically within earshot.”
Vanity vs. Actionable Metrics
Vanity Metrics: Impressions, followers, completion rates, household reach.
What it measures: air
Actionability: low
Outcome: dopamine hits, invoice justification, zero ROI
Actionable Metrics: Conversions, revenue, trust, attention quality.
What it measures: growth
Actionability: high
Outcome: actual impact, brand longevity, money in the bank
The Punch
Your career — and your brand — won’t be measured by how many AI-powered dashboards you flashed at Cannes or how many times you dropped “machine learning” into a pitch deck.
It’ll be measured by whether the work actually moved the needle. Whether sales went up. Whether customers cared. Whether the brand became stronger tomorrow than it was yesterday.
The risk in 2025 isn’t missing the next shiny “insight.” It’s drowning in dashboards and mistaking noise for progress. Every minute spent tweaking a metric that doesn’t matter is a minute stolen from building something that does.
So ask yourself: are you building businesses, or just optimizing reports until the next reorg? Because when the dashboards glitch, the slide decks fade, and the AI horoscope stops predicting, the only thing left will be the work that actually mattered.
The Universal Marketing Horoscope Dashboard™
Metric | What It Pretends to Mean | What It Actually Means | Horoscope Spin |
---|---|---|---|
Impressions | Your brand is “everywhere” | Your ad flashed by like a pigeon in Times Square | “A million people walked past you and didn’t look up.” |
Completion Rate (CTV) | Viewers are captivated! | They couldn’t skip the ad even if they wanted to | “You held their attention the way a dentist holds jaws.” |
Impression Share | You “dominated the market.” | You bought air time no one was watching | “The stars say you’re shouting into a void — loudly.” |
Household Reach | Unique households saw your brilliance | TVs played to empty couches and sleeping dogs | “Your message resonated with the furniture.” |
Followers | People love your brand | Half are bots, the other half don’t remember following you | “Admiration flows, mostly from click farms in Manila.” |
Pageviews | Audiences are flooding your site | They bounced in 3 seconds after Googling the wrong thing | “Traffic is rising… like tourists lost in your lobby.” |
Email Open Rate | Customers are engaged | They clicked to delete, not to read | “Inbox alignment is strong, but interest is weak.” |
Engagement Rate | Customers are “leaning in” | They liked your post because their thumb slipped | “The universe suggests shallow interaction is imminent.” |
