Our Amazing Sponsor

📦 Part 4: The Great Reset – Rebuilding Marketing Without the Algorithm Crutch

Let’s be honest.

You’ve been letting your media strategy be driven by a lobotomized Roomba with a WiFi connection and a caffeine problem.

Over the past three parts, we’ve dismantled the religion of optimization, point by delusional point. And now, we’re going to say the quiet part out loud, in bold, with a bullhorn and probably a little profanity if someone doesn’t stop me.

Here's your no-BS recap of what we’ve actually learned — no dashboards, no excuses, just truth.

🤖 The Machines Are Doing Their Job—Just Not Yours

Let’s call this what it is: the platforms are great at one thing—optimizing for the most superficial metric you give them.

Tell the algorithm to chase clicks, and congrats, you just bought yourself an army of compulsive clickers, rage tappers, and bots with a gambling addiction.

Want ROAS? It'll show your ads to people who already had their wallets out—like congratulating the waiter for delivering a check after the customer already finished their meal. It’s credit-stealing on autopilot, and you’re the one footing the bill.

🧠 These tools don’t care about nuance. They don’t care about intent, value, LTV, or whether your customer actually likes you. They care about the easiest win, the fastest dopamine spike, and the shortest path to a spreadsheet that looks good in a QBR.

🧼 You Let Platforms Write Your Strategy (While They Robbed You Blind)

Somewhere along the way, you outsourced critical thinking to the very companies designed to profit off your laziness.

You gave Meta, Google, TikTok and their black-box bidding systems the keys to your media budget, then acted shocked when your CAC looked like it had just gotten back from a weekend in Vegas.

Let’s get one thing crystal clear: If your entire strategy lives inside a platform’s “smart” settings, you don’t have a strategy.
You have a glorified vending machine.
And guess what? That vending machine is broken.

Instead of candy, it's spitting out overpriced nonsense like:

  • “Smart” campaigns that cannibalize your organic traffic

  • “Optimized” creatives that are more robotic than a Tesla customer support chatbot

  • And targeting logic that somehow thinks your best customer is a 65-year-old man in Nebraska because he once clicked on a banner ad while scrolling through WebMD

This isn’t strategy. It’s slot machine marketing.
And the house? Yeah, it always wins.

👻 The Middle of Your Funnel Is Ghosted Harder Than a Tinder Date in 2012

Mid-funnel is where consideration happens. Where people decide if they like you, trust you, and maybe, just maybe, want to give you money.

But your platforms? They treat it like a bad sequel—forgettable, unimportant, and definitely not getting budget.

You throw case studies, testimonial videos, product comparisons, and buyer guides into your campaigns and the algorithm looks at them like a picky toddler being handed a plate of vegetables.

🥬 "Too slow."
🥦 "Not clicky enough."
🍆 "Where’s the conversion, bro?"

So the content that builds actual belief—gets buried.
Gone. Forgotten. Starved of spend like a side character in your customer journey.

If you’ve ever wondered why brand affinity is cratering or why your CAC is bloated—it’s because you abandoned the part of the funnel where decisions actually get made.

🚬 Retargeting Is the Nicotine Patch of Marketing

Let’s talk about your favorite addiction: retargeting.

Yeah, it feels great. Like a warm blanket of “at least I’m doing something.”
But here’s the hard truth: it’s the comfort food of marketing.
Junk calories. Zero nutritional value.

Retargeting doesn’t build demand. It skims off the top.
It’s a lazy river of ad spend that just floats past the same cart abandoners over and over like Groundhog Day but with banner ads.

Here’s how it plays out:

  • 🚨 You serve 9 ads to someone who already planned to come back

  • 💰 You pay for that “conversion” like it was a heroic act

  • 📉 You show a strong ROAS on paper

  • 😬 Meanwhile, your top-of-funnel has been starving for six quarters

Congratulations. You just paid a toll to cross a bridge you already owned.
You're not marketing. You're playing "who gets credit for this sale" with a machine.

⚰️ The Real Punchline: If Your Strategy Can Be Fully Automated, You Don’t Have One

Let me say that again louder for the folks in the attribution weeds:

If your entire marketing program can be automated inside a DSP, you don’t have a strategy.

You have a spreadsheet cosplay version of growth that exists to placate stakeholders and feed the machine, not serve customers or build anything real.

This is what we’ve built:

  • A funnel with no middle

  • A growth strategy built on retargeting fumes

  • A dashboard that rewards the wrong metrics and punishes real marketing

  • An ad budget that goes to whoever shows up last in the buyer journey and has the best timestamp

🧨 Final Thought: Time to Pull the Plug

Look, you can keep pretending this is working.
You can keep feeding the beast.

Or—you can do the hard, messy, grown-up thing and actually build something that matters.

Reinvest in mid-funnel
Demand incrementality
Stop giving your budget to platforms that punish strategy
Treat ROAS like your ex: useful once, dangerous now, and not worth going back to

This is your wake-up call.

The alarm’s been ringing for three straight columns.
Time to roll out of bed and rethink the entire game.

Because the machines?
They’re not broken.

They’re just not on your side.

🛠️ THE REBUILD — THREE NEW RULES TO MARKET LIKE A MENSCH

If the past three chapters were about tearing down your house of algorithmic cards, this one’s about building something real—something human, something that won’t collapse every time Google updates its “trust signals” or TikTok decides your brand’s no longer cool.

We’re done pretending that “optimization” means anything beyond squeezing one more fraction of a percent out of a very tired, very abused clickstream.

Let’s talk about how to rebuild. From the ashes of clickbait performance, from the ghost town that is your mid-funnel, and from the cold mechanical hands of programmatic junk logic.

Let’s market like a mensch—with intention, with nuance, and with a backbone.

🧩 Rule One: Build Demand—Don’t Just Harvest It

(aka Stop Acting Like QVC with Better Fonts)

Here’s a fun little marketing hallucination:
You run some paid search ads. People click. People buy. You pat yourself on the back.

Except… they were already going to buy. They typed your name. Or your competitor’s. Or “best [whatever] for [desperate problem].”
The machine just showed up at the finish line and took credit like a drunk wedding guest jumping into the bouquet toss.

That’s not marketing. That’s harvesting demand someone else created—probably your competitor, or worse, your PR team.

📉 What happens when you only harvest?
You run out. You dry up. You become a discount faucet with a logo.

The brands that thrive?
They make people want them.
Over time. Across touchpoints. Like a great movie trailer that keeps popping into your head even though you didn’t ask for it.

📺 Think HBO, not HSN.
HBO builds lore, builds hype, builds emotional contracts.
HSN shouts “LIMITED TIME OFFER” until your ears bleed.

If your marketing doesn’t create desire, you’re just fighting over leftovers.

How to Actually Build Demand Like a Mensch:

  • 🧠 Create content that doesn’t convert today—but makes people curious tomorrow

  • 📽️ Run mini-docs, explainer series, founder stories—stop selling, start storytelling

  • 🧪 Accept that some campaigns will look “inefficient” but build the pipeline you’ll need six months from now

  • 🎯 Rethink success: use brand lift studies, search volume trends, and social sentiment as KPIs—yes, those still matter

  • 💡 Hire people who know what a story arc is—not just how to write a CTA

Look around: the brands winning hearts (and revenue) aren’t optimizing for today’s click. They’re engineering longing. They’re curating curiosity.

That’s not fluff. That’s strategy.

🧭 Rule Two: Make iROAS Your North Star

(aka Stop Worshipping ROAS Like It's a Golden Calf)

Let me say this one slow for the data team in the back:

ROAS is a vanity metric.

It’s like giving your roommate credit for cooking dinner because they lit the candle after you served the meal.
Looks pretty. Smells nice. Means nothing.

🚨 ROAS only tells you what happened after the ad showed up.
Not whether the ad mattered.
Not whether the customer needed it.
Not whether you changed the outcome.

That’s where iROAS comes in: Incremental Return on Ad Spend.
The grown-up metric. The one that asks, “Would this have happened without us?”

If your marketing didn’t change the outcome, why are you celebrating?
You’re not driving revenue. You’re collecting IOUs from conversions that were already on the way.

Here's Your New Metric Stack (Memorize It. Tattoo It. Frame It.):

  • 📈 iROAS – Did we create revenue or just rent it?

  • 📊 Brand Lift – Did we move perception or just pixels?

  • 👀 View-Through Conversions – Who saw but didn’t click… and still came back?

  • 🧮 LTV:CAC – Are we growing value, or just burning through acquisition?

  • 📖 Engagement Depth – Are people watching, reading, caring—or just scrolling?

Every smart brand you admire already made this shift.
They’re not looking at ROAS dashboards like gospel. They’re studying patterns. Nurture cycles. Sentiment over time.

Because revenue with no relationship is just a one-night stand.
iROAS tells you who’s falling in love.

🧨 Rule Three: Practice Strategic Inefficiency

(aka Be Brave Enough to Look Like a Fool on Paper)

Let’s rip the Band-Aid off:
The cleanest data is usually the dumbest.
Because the more “trackable” your campaign, the more likely you’re just riding coattails.

Real impact? It's messy. It's hard to prove.
It lives in the dark corners of human behavior—DMs, watercooler convos, Slack threads, TikTok stitches.

But that’s where trust is born. That’s where momentum lives.

Time to Get Comfortable with Good Inefficiency:

💡 Tactical Area

😬 “Inefficient” Action

🚀 Strategic Benefit

Content Marketing

Long-form guides, no CTA

Thought leadership, SEO gravity

Community Building

Host AMAs, forums, no sales pitch

Retention, fandom, feedback loops

Creative Testing

Run wild, non-performing variants

Discover new tone, new triggers

Brand Experiences

Untrackable but immersive events

Social sharing, brand memorability

Run the ad that doesn’t convert today—but makes someone bring you up in a conversation next week.
Invest in the influencer who can’t spell CPM but moves people to care.
Write the explainer no one clicks but everyone reads once they’re actually interested.

Stop chasing algorithmic hygiene. Start chasing emotional messiness.
Because that’s where real brand-building happens.

💡 The Big Shift:

This isn’t about swapping one metric for another or shifting 5% of spend.
It’s about rejecting platform-induced myopia in favor of long-term market gravity.

The brands that are going to dominate the next decade?

  • 🧠 Will measure what matters, not just what’s visible

  • 🧍‍♂️ Will act like humans, not machines

  • 🎭 Will trade transactional efficiency for emotional depth

Because honestly?
The performance cult is cracking.
The dashboard worship is getting embarrassing.
And your customers? They’re not data points. They’re people.

So let’s act like it.

🧠 You’ve Reached the End of the Free Ride… Or Have You? 👉 Upgrade to ADOTAT+. Cheaper than a burnt oat milk latte and way more satisfying.

Stay Bold. Stay Curious. Know More Than You Did Yesterday.—

👉 click there for this offer, join ADOTAT+, and get a full month of paid content free.

logo

Subscribe to our premium content at ADOTAT+ to read the rest.

Become a paying subscriber to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.

Upgrade

Keep Reading