In partnership with

Ready to level up your work with AI?

HubSpot’s free guide to using ChatGPT at work is your new cheat code to go from working hard to hardly working

HubSpot’s guide will teach you:

• How to prompt like a pro

• How to integrate AI in your personal workflow

• Over 100+ useful prompt ideas

All in order to help you unleash the power of AI for a more efficient, impactful professional life.

Get the free guide and level up your AI game today!

Once upon a time, the internet was a bustling metropolis where publishers, bloggers, and digital darlings thrived, feeding on a steady diet of clicks and social shares. Fast-forward to 2020, and the digital landscape started looking like a ghost town. Traffic is plummeting, referral links are drying up, and publishers are realizing they’ve built their empires on rented land. And guess who’s been tinkering with the lease? Social media platforms, algorithms, and now, the new kid on the block, AI.

Let’s not mince words: the internet as we knew it is in the midst of a full-blown midlife crisis. It’s not sporting a new car or dating someone half its age (unless you count rebranding as Meta or X), but the symptoms are unmistakable—declining engagement, disappearing traffic, and a desperate attempt to cling to relevance in a world that’s moved on.

The Algorithmic Betrayal: When Facebook and Twitter Pulled the Plug

Once the lifeblood of referral traffic, social media platforms have turned into the ultimate frenemy. In their early days, they were the golden geese, funneling traffic to publishers who happily feasted on the spoils. Then came the algorithmic rug-pull. Facebook (now Meta) and Twitter (now X, because rebranding totally fixes existential problems) decided that news links weren’t worth the effort anymore. Why? Because angry comment wars drive more engagement than well-researched journalism.

BuzzFeed, for example, went from thriving to merely surviving. Back in 2020, Facebook accounted for 13.7% of their traffic. By 2023, that number shrank to a paltry 5.6%. And that’s not even the worst of it. The Washington Post, once a digital juggernaut, has seen daily active users nosedive from 22.5 million in January 2021 to a depressing 2.5 million by the 2024 elections. That’s an 85-90% plunge—basically the digital equivalent of a freefall with no parachute.

Even right-wing stalwarts like The Drudge Report aren’t immune. Their unique visitors have dropped 81% since 2020. Turns out, algorithms are equal-opportunity destroyers, cutting off lifelines whether you’re serving up left-leaning think pieces or far-right conspiracy fodder.

Enter Google’s AI: The Robot That Stole Your Audience

Just when publishers thought it couldn’t get worse, Google decided to upend the game with its AI Overviews—a feature that distills search results into bite-sized summaries. Great for users in a hurry, catastrophic for publishers whose business models rely on clicks. Why bother visiting a site when Google gives you the TL;DR version right on the results page?

For some publishers, the impact has been “negligible”—which is PR-speak for “we’re pretending it doesn’t hurt.” For others, it’s been devastating. A Press Gazette study found that AI-generated summaries appear in nearly 24% of news-related search queries, pushing actual links further down the page. Organic search traffic has become an endangered species, and publishers are scrambling to figure out what’s next.

Some industry insiders predict that Google’s AI-driven Search Generative Experience (SGE) could slash organic search traffic by 20-60%, potentially costing publishers up to $2 billion annually in lost ad revenue. And if that wasn’t enough, traditional SEO strategies are becoming about as effective as MySpace ads in 2024. Search ranking factors mean less when AI-generated answers are the shiny new toy.

Publishers’ Media Kits: A Crisis of Confidence

Here’s where things go from bad to worse. You’d think publishers would respond to these challenges with innovation and transparency. Instead, many are clinging to outdated media kits that are about as appealing as a Blockbuster membership in the age of Netflix. Inflated metrics? Check. Stale traffic numbers? Double check. These cookie-cutter PDFs are doing little more than screaming, “We stopped trying.”

Advertisers aren’t buying it—literally or figuratively. They want live dashboards, real-time insights, and proof that publishers can still deliver. Instead, they’re getting a PowerPoint presentation from 2015. It’s not just embarrassing; it’s a death knell in an industry where trust and adaptability are everything.

The Way Forward: Evolve or Die

Publishers, it’s time for some tough love. The world doesn’t owe you clicks. Social media platforms aren’t going to change their algorithms to suit your needs. Google isn’t going to dial back its AI innovation just because your traffic is tanking. The only way forward is to adapt—or risk irrelevance.

Here’s what you need to do:

1. Get Real with Metrics
   Stop inflating numbers or relying on page views as your sole selling point. Advertisers care about engagement, time spent, and conversion rates. Invest in live dashboards that showcase real-time data, not recycled metrics.

2. Embrace Curation
   If you can’t compete on volume, compete on quality. Curated marketplaces and premium audience segments are the future. Offer advertisers something they can’t get elsewhere—whether it’s access to niche audiences or brand-safe environments.

3. Experiment with Formats
   Static banners are yesterday’s news. Lean into shoppable ads, interactive content, and video. Show advertisers that you’re not just keeping up with trends but setting them.

4. Diversify Traffic Sources
   Social media and search aren’t the only games in town. Double down on newsletters, podcasts, and direct app traffic. Build channels where you control the audience relationship.

5. Tell a Better Story
   Your media kit should be a narrative, not a spreadsheet. Highlight your unique value proposition, success stories, and creative solutions. Make advertisers excited to work with you.

The Bottom Line: Sink or Swim

The digital landscape isn’t dying—it’s evolving. Yes, AI and algorithms have thrown publishers into a tailspin, but they’ve also created opportunities for those willing to innovate. The question is, will publishers rise to the challenge or go the way of the dodo? The choice is yours. Stay bold, stay curious, and adapt before it’s too late. Otherwise, the next time someone talks about you, it’ll be in the past tense.

Pesach Lattin
Editor, ADOTAT
[email protected] 

Got 10 friends who love snarky adtech insights as much as you do? Refer them to ADOTAT, and we’ll upgrade you to ADOTAT+—free for a month! That’s exclusive content, insider scoops, and a front-row seat to the ad industry's circus, all for spreading the good word. No sales pitches, just click and share. Because who doesn’t love a free VIP pass to brilliance?

The Premium Mirage: Why Publishers Need to Get Real or Get Left Behind

Let’s stop kidding ourselves—“premium” is the digital world’s most overused, under-delivered buzzword. It’s been tossed around like a free tote bag at a conference, but here’s the problem: in 2025, no one’s buying it unless you back it up. Publishers are learning the hard way that the old formula—high-quality content + high traffic = guaranteed revenue—is about as cutting-edge as a flip phone at CES. If you’re still clinging to that outdated playbook, you’re basically walking into a Formula 1 race with a horse and buggy, and everyone else is laughing as they lap you.

Subscribe to our premium content at ADOTAT+ to read the rest.