Sign up here | Advertise? Comments? |
|---|
You’ve seen them slither into meetings.
Pitch-deck preachers. LinkedIn prophets. “Strategic consultants” who think DSP stands for Don’t Show Proficiency.
Your boss paid them $5,000 to “upskill” the agency. They used it on bottle service, bad decisions, and a “training deck” stolen from someone else’s keynote. Then they mumbled something about “funnel velocity” and couldn’t diagram a single stage if you handed them crayons.
Now they’re quoting ADOTAT+ like they came up with it.
Our Amazing Sponsor
The Paradox of the “Good Guy”
Why Everyone Seems to Hate The Trade Desk
The Trade Desk loves to posture as the tireless defender of the open web — planting its flag as the noble alternative to Google, Meta, and Amazon.
But as its tentacles spread deeper into the programmatic ecosystem, the company increasingly resembles a walled garden in sheep’s clothing.
Just ask the agencies: first, they’re courted with sweet talk about “partnerships” and transparency; then, they wake up to find themselves quietly sidelined as TTD pushes more direct publisher integrations and self-serve optimizations.
The honeymoon turned into a hangover faster than a Cannes yacht party.
Meanwhile, publishers aren’t exactly singing love songs either.
They grumble about OpenPath, probe the fine print in default settings, and question just how “open” TTD’s version of openness really is. On the competitive front, rivals do what rivals do — run whisper campaigns, leak shade into podcasts, and obsessively parse Jeff Green’s every word.
Depending on who you ask, he’s Darth Vader with a Bloomberg terminal or Yoda with a Bloomberg account.
Sometimes both in the same sentence.
If you think all this is messy, wait until you see how The Trade Desk’s strategy plays out in real time — that drama unfolds in the paid section.
Hero, Villain, or Something in Between?
The Trade Desk’s role in adtech has become a Rorschach test. Whether you see a hero or a villain depends entirely on where you sit in the ecosystem:
The “Good Guy” Arguments
Championing the Open Internet: TTD markets itself as the antidote to Big Tech oligopolies, promising advertisers transparency, objectivity, and measurement across the “premium open internet.”
Independence as a Feature: Advertisers and some agencies genuinely appreciate TTD’s independence, especially in fast-growth spaces like CTV, where other players are locked inside walled gardens.
Retention and Growth: Customer retention hovers over 95%, and despite a softer ad market, TTD still outpaces most of its peers on revenue and profit.
The “Bad Guy” Criticisms
Walled Garden in Disguise: Rivals and publishers argue OpenPath isn’t open at all — it just reroutes power toward TTD. Default settings don’t look like neutrality, they look like consolidation.
Agency Tensions: Agencies who once built their trading desks on TTD now find themselves elbowed aside as brands are wooed directly.
Market Power: Whisper campaigns point to the obvious — TTD is increasingly powerful, and with power comes the same suspicion and resentment lobbed at the giants it claims to check.
Transparency vs. Profit: Critics say transparency is just marketing varnish on an engine built for profit. When the chips are down, money beats mission.
Jeff Green: Prophet or Opportunist?
Here’s where it gets personal. One longtime industry friend confided off the record that Jeff Green isn’t the same guy he was a decade ago. After losing his religion and divorcing his wife — once described as his moral compass — he’s allegedly stopped trying to be the “good guy” and instead doubled down on making as much money as possible.
And the receipts? They’re hard to ignore.
Compensation Package Theater: Green’s 2021 pay deal was originally valued at $819 million and ballooned into a potential $5.2 billion jackpot if share-price milestones are hit. It sparked shareholder lawsuits, but Delaware’s Chancery Court shrugged in 2025, ruling there was no bad faith or misconduct.
Stock-Based Compensation Dependence: About 20% of TTD’s revenue is tied to stock-based comp, feeding the narrative that executives — especially Green — are laser-focused on personal gain.
Aggressive Targets: Green is very public about his goal to double revenue to $5 billion by 2027. Admirable ambition, sure, but critics argue it overshadows the “open web” mission.
The Counterpoints
To be fair, there’s another lens:
Founder-Led Alignment: Green owns about 8.5% of the company. His fate is directly tied to TTD’s, which investors like to see.
Performance-Linked Pay: His mega-package only pays if the stock soars — meaning shareholders benefit, too.
Legal Clean Bill: Unlike Elon Musk’s recent Delaware courtroom drama, Green’s pay package was reviewed and cleared.
Where the Industry Lands
Jeff Green is clearly motivated by money, but so are most founder-CEOs in tech. The difference is that TTD has spent a decade dressing itself up as principled Robin Hood of programmatic.
Now that the mask is slipping, people can’t decide whether to admire the hustle or resent the hypocrisy.
The reality is complicated: TTD is neither saint nor villain.
It’s a highly adaptive, aggressively strategic player that preaches openness while consolidating power — and that makes people nervous.
The real question is whether TTD’s actions expand opportunity for the broader ecosystem or simply rebuild programmatic’s power silos under a new brand name.
The Rabbi of ROAS
Sidebar: The Trade Desk Under Pressure
Valuation Reset
Oppenheimer’s Jason Helfstein cut his price target to $70 after TTD’s 30% post-earnings slide. Shares trade at ~25x forward cash flow — still rich, but not out of line with Roku (21x) and above Meta (15x). Near-term downside to $15 is possible, but he sees a rebound above $20 next quarter.
Amazon’s Shadow
Investors bristled at TTD’s dismissal of Amazon. Helfstein argues Amazon’s DSP is a real threat in CPG (≈15% of TTD’s business) but far weaker in auto, finance, telecom, and travel — categories Amazon lacks data depth.
Execution Risks
Management turnover, including a new CFO and sales head, adds pressure. Kokai, TTD’s new platform, must prove it can deliver 20% better revenue and advertiser performance to reassure investors.
What You’re Missing in ADOTAT+
Part 2: The Mechanics of Distrust
This is where we tear open the black box. In the paid section, I break down how The Trade Desk actually makes enemies — not just with whispers, but with product decisions that reshape the supply chain.
How Kokai’s default settings didn’t “optimize” so much as bulldoze certain SSPs into irrelevance.
Why agencies that once worshipped at the altar of Jeff Green now feel like they’ve been ghosted on a bad Tinder date.
And the dirty little secret: third-party data on the open web has always been garbage, yet TTD keeps buying more lipstick for the same pig.
This isn’t opinion — it’s where the receipts live.
Part 3: Principles vs. Power
Then we zoom out to the bigger picture — is TTD really saving the open internet, or just building a shinier fiefdom?
Why obsessing over TTD’s stock price is a distraction from the realpolitik of programmatic.
How Jeff Green’s pay package and personal pivot reveal more about his incentives than any keynote ever will.
Why the industry’s fantasy of a DSP-as-savior ignores one inconvenient truth: capitalism eats prophets for breakfast.
Think Machiavelli, not Moses. You don’t build an “open web” on hope and press releases. You build it with leverage, ruthless scale, and a willingness to play just as dirty as the giants you claim to fight.
Why You Should Have Bought ADOTAT+
If you stopped at the free section, you got the appetizer. ADOTAT+ is the steak — bloody, messy, and not for the faint of heart.
You’ll know why agencies whisper about being punished.
You’ll see how publishers get squeezed even when they play by the rules.
You’ll understand why Jeff Green gets cast as both Yoda and Darth Vader — sometimes in the same sentence.
And if you’re in this industry — agency, publisher, brand, or adtech hustler — the playbook isn’t optional. It’s survival.
Subscribe to ADOTAT+ to read the rest.
Unlock the full ADOTAT+ experience—access exclusive content, hand-picked daily stats, expert insights, and private interviews that break it all down. This isn’t just a newsletter; it’s your edge in staying ahead.
Upgrade