This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsor: Troutman Amin LLP, Deserve to Win.

James McDonald gets a call from Google almost every week, on behalf of one client or another, telling him he needs to buy more search. He has a standing answer. It is not the one Google wants.

James McDonald runs Audience Group, the Sydney media agency he co-founded about twelve years before we spoke. He started as a media planner at OMD around the turn of the century, comes from an advertising family, and has strong views about paid search. I asked him the main ripoff. He did not need to think.

“They're marking their own homework. That's the main ripoff. You're trusting a platform to spend your money and tell you if it's working or not.”

His analogy is the best I have heard on the subject. “I liken search to putting an ad outside a supermarket on a poster saying, buy Campbell's soup. And then saying every can of soup within the supermarket that got bought was because of that ad.”

Then the claim, from a man who inherits other agencies' search accounts for a living. He says he has never seen real incrementality from a search campaign, unless the previous agency had been running it badly. Take over a long-running account, switch off a random quarter of it, and, in his experience, the client's profit does not move.

The weekly calls from Google tell him the opposite: buy your own brand terms, be number one, buy more. I added the part that makes brand search even stranger. When people search a brand name, the results are often coupon sites, so the brand pays to send its own buyer to a discount. “And there's no empirical evidence that discounting makes more profit for any client,” he said. “You're setting a price expectation that's lower than what you want it to be. And there's no loyalty from a cheap price either. So you're losing both ways.”

He is not anti-search. That is what makes the critique stick. Search, he says, is what replaced the Yellow Pages. If you need a plumber now, you search. It is shelf space, especially for services brands without physical distribution, and local search matters when you are out looking for a pub tonight. “It's not that search isn't important. It's massively overstated.”

Search is a directory that learned to bill like a salesman. That is his whole argument, and it is worth more than most attribution decks.

Frequency is a tax

McDonald's line about frequency is the one people quote back to him: it is the tax you pay for not being remembered. The industry, he says, still clings to the old rule of three, the idea that someone has to see an ad three times before it sticks. His view is the opposite. Reach people once, wait until they start to forget, then hit them again. “The key to frequency is finding out when people start forgetting and then hit them again, rather than trying to hit them a certain number of times so they remember forever.”

He learned it the hard way. As a young planner at OMD, he crammed a client's TV budget into a short burst of heavy frequency, believing he could make people remember so well the brand would not need to advertise again for a long time. “It just failed miserably.”

The success story came later, with a client trying to break into Sydney, an expensive TV market, that had been pouring weight into linear and connected TV with no frequency control. Given the product's consideration cycle, his team decided people only needed to be reached about once a month. They shaved off the excess frequency and moved it into incremental reach, with the same budget and the same creative. Over the next 18 months, he says, the client gained market share points and the business grew about 30 percent. He was careful to add it was not the only factor.

His favorite brand example is Coca-Cola, and the logic is beautiful. Coke's real reach is every refrigerator in every convenience store and McDonald's on earth. So its broadcast ads target light buyers, the people who drink two or three Cokes a year. The holiday ad gets remembered for months, and the fridge triggers the memory at the moment of purchase. “That's perfect reach.”

Subscribe to keep reading

This content won’t cost you a dime, but here’s the catch: you need to be subscribed to ADOTAT – your front-row seat to everything Adtech, Marketing, and Media – to keep the good stuff coming.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now