About two thirds of the way through, the lights in her office shut off on a motion timer. She had been sitting still, telling me why brands should stop obsessing over direct response. It felt like the building had an opinion.
Cristy Garcia is the chief marketing officer of impact.com, the partnership management platform that brands use to run affiliate, influencer and referral programs. She has been in affiliate for most of her career, and she opened by naming the thing she has been fighting the whole time.
“This has been the bane of my existence for the past 15, 20 years that I've been working in this industry. It's the perception that affiliate marketing is less than other channels, that there are bottom feeders, that there's no incremental value that comes from affiliate marketing. This is the hardest myth to dispel.”
She is right that the reputation exists. I spent years in performance marketing and I know exactly the tone of voice she means. She blames three things: attribution fights and last-click bias, the association with coupon and discount sites, and the fact that most people outside the channel do not understand how it works.
Her bumper sticker for the industry, when I asked for one: “Don't sleep on affiliate marketing.”
So far, a CMO defending her category. Fine. That is the job. The interesting part came later, when I asked what trend she is most excited about, and she gave an answer that cuts against the product she sells.
She said companies are finally putting brand ahead of demand. After five years of “revenue, revenue, revenue, revenue,” she said, marketers are learning that revenue shows up on its own when people already know who you are.
“Everything is cheaper, faster, better when your audience knows your brand.”
She went further. Some companies, she said, are quitting paid advertising altogether, and she named brands she says have built themselves without it: Spanx, Zara, Rolls-Royce.
Then, without my asking, she told me what she actually does with her own money.
“I don't know if I'm pivoting anytime soon. Most of my budget goes to direct response campaigns.”
There it is. The CMO who sells the performance channel says brand is what makes everything work, and spends most of her own budget on performance anyway. I do not think that makes her a hypocrite. I think it makes her the most honest witness I have had on this subject, because she just demonstrated the problem in one breath: everybody believes in brand, and nobody's CFO does.
“Anybody can be a publisher”
I asked where the bottom-feeder myth actually lives, with the clients or inside the industry. She did not hedge. “I think it's within the clients. The industry has tried really hard to rebrand around partnerships.” The rebrand is real, and you have heard it: not affiliates, partners. Other businesses. Influencers. Charity sites. “Anybody can be a publisher.”
The channel is climbing the org chart anyway, she says, “moving beyond an afterthought to more of a strategic component,” pulled upward by the one thing CFOs cannot resist: you only pay when it works. But she was honest about the ceiling, and her word for the alternative is one I plan to steal. The tried-and-true channels are “coin operated.” Put the money in, the impressions come out. “Affiliate marketing is none of those things. It's personal, it takes time to build.”
That is the real reason the channel stays underrated, and it has nothing to do with coupons. Budgets flow to whatever can be bought in bulk by Thursday. Relationships do not come in bulk. Neither does trust. The industry rebranded around partnerships because that is what the thing actually is, and partnership is precisely what a media plan has no cell for.
“I went into marketing because I'm not into math”
She explained the trap herself, a few minutes earlier, when I asked what would surprise people about being a CMO.
“CMOs are really expected to be data-driven, but not all marketing outcomes are quantified. Brand perception, customer sentiment, word of mouth. These are things that are incredibly hard to measure but critical for growth.”
The hard part, she said, is “the need to constantly defend marketing initiatives to stakeholders that are looking for things like hard numbers in areas where you just can't find them.” She called it the black box of marketing.
Which is exactly why affiliate is having its moment in the boardroom. It is the one line item that answers the CFO's question before he asks it.
“If every one of my marketing channels could work that way, if every time I said I'm only paying for results, I would be incredibly fortunate and a very good CMO. But channels don't work like that, except for affiliate.”
The job itself turned out to be less creative and more spreadsheet than she expected. “I went into marketing because I'm not into math. But as a CMO, I've had to learn the numbers.” EBITDA. ARR. Net revenue retention. None of it taught in marketing school.
And the rule she would rewrite, if she could rewrite one: the idea that marketing is a cost center. It is the first budget cut in a downturn because it is discretionary and easy to control. “If the marketing team is driving revenue and driving awareness for your business, turning that off is like biting off your arm.”

