This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

In partnership with

Troutman Amin LLP

Here is a sentence you will not find in a single ad tech pitch deck: this industry has an expiration date.

Not “is evolving.” Not “is being reimagined.” Expires. Gets replaced by something that does the same job without needing most of the companies currently invoicing for it.

Matthew Wolff Simon said it anyway. On The ADOTAT Show, the one with the cold open, the Troutman Amin spot and a guest who answers questions faster than most people can spell “programmatic.”

“Ad tech is an intermediary stage.”

Matthew was homeless at 20. Since then he has lived in five countries, picked up seven languages to varying degrees of beer-ordering competence, and built a team he says grew to 250 people. He has appeared on UK national television twice, and he has lost on Mastermind, the BBC quiz show with the black leather chair, with Ayn Rand as his specialist subject. More on that humiliation below.

He is now a partner at Xool Media & Tech, an ad tech company. Which makes his thesis even better: the man thinks the house is temporary, and he just bought into the neighborhood.

I spent an hour with him in June, and the conversation kept circling one idea. Ad tech is not the end of anything. It is a middle step, a set of pipes between a brand and a customer who would, in a better design, simply find each other. Matthew gives the middle step about fifteen years. I think he is more right about the diagnosis than the timeline, and I think the industry is about to discover how much of its revenue lives in the pipes.

I also noticed something that I suspect will annoy a lot of people in the industry. Matthew is not an ad tech romantic. He does not talk about attention, creative magic or the sacred bond between brands and consumers. He talks about invoices, staffing models and whether a yes means yes. For an industry that sells dreams by the CPM, that is the equivalent of a magician explaining the trap door. Some of you will hate it. Most of you should listen.

Watch the full episode: Matthew Wolff Simon on The ADOTAT Show, on YouTube. Thirty minutes, five plain-English fact cards, zero product pitches.

14% Annualized: Meet CHAD, Nasdaq-Listed Preferred Stock

Meet CHAD (Nasdaq: CHAD), DeFi Development Corp.'s variable-rate perpetual preferred stock. CHAD currently offers a 14% annualized dividend rate, paid each business day when declared. Based on its current balance sheet, DFDV estimates more than 100 years of dividend coverage. Learn how CHAD works and see the full risk disclosures at whoischad.com.

CHAD is variable-rate preferred stock. Dividends are not guaranteed, and the dividend rate may change. Investment involves risk, including possible loss of principal. CHAD is not FDIC insured. For important risks, disclosures, and prospectus, visit whoischad.com/disclaimer.

Fifteen more years

His case starts with a bit of philosophy most ad tech CEOs would need explained to them twice.

The Copernican principle, as he puts it: you are probably somewhere in the middle of whatever you are looking at, not at its beginning or its end. He puts ad tech at about fifteen years old. Take that, and the average remaining life of the thing is roughly another fifteen years. Which is a very generous way of saying the industry has a mortgage and no idea when the bank calls.

Then comes the mechanism. Advertising, he says, is a way of disseminating information. It steers consumer choice toward a brand. And increasingly, people run big parts of their lives through AI, which means the ad stops being the thing that talks to you and starts being the thing your agent reads before it decides what you need.

His picture: a personal agent, trained on your smart fridge, your bank account and your Amazon history, decides what you need, gets approval from a human in the loop, and buys the product directly from whatever retailer carries it. The AI gathers the specs. The AI helps you choose. The AI, in short, does the shopping while the ad industry sits in the food court, waiting for someone to come by and pitch the pretzels.

So who exactly is the ad tech stack showing an ad to?

I pushed back. Isn’t that the territory replacing the map? The job survives. Only the plumbing changes.

He took the point, then made it worse for the plumbers. The true goal of ad tech, and of marketing in general, is to unite an individual or a company with the products they want. If that gets cut out of the middle, the current structure gives way to something else entirely, and that something else is buying directly through an AI interface. The interface, in his telling, becomes the new billboard, except nobody will be looking at it, because the agent is already reading it for you.

The map is not the territory. That line belongs to Alfred Korzybski. Matthew got the attribution right, which puts him ahead of most keynote speakers.

Ad serving is middleware

In his pre-show questionnaire, Matthew wrote that too many people in ad tech have never worked anywhere else. On air, he walked that back like a man who had just realized he’d said something at a dinner party. “That’s probably a slightly more dramatic version of my opinion than is really true.”

Then he said the more interesting thing anyway.

When he started in ad tech, people were hired on their ad tech credentials rather than on their technology, account management or other skills. He thinks that produced worse results than hiring from the wider software market would have. Which, if you’ve ever sat through a vendor pitch where the chief revenue officer explains the bidstream using a metaphor about fishing, you will recognize as a fair cop.

His central point: ad serving is middleware. The technical logic, the compliance logic and the operational logic are, in his telling, comparable to fintech, to financial messaging services and to SaaS generally.

“It’s IT for IT.”

Should ad tech be more like fintech, then? He reached for Tolstoy. All happy families are alike. Every dysfunction is unhappy in its own way. His fix is the same everywhere: borrow best practice from adjacent fields and hire talent “from wherever it may best manifest itself.”

I asked him what the wider software world has figured out that ad tech has not. He said I was overstating the case, which is a polite way of saying I was right and he would prefer I not say so in print. I am saying so in print.

The part of this argument that I think ad tech will hate most is the fraud problem. Matthew treats the infrastructure as something you can run with normal software discipline. But a payments company is not fighting bots that get paid to pretend to be shoppers. An ad server might be. That difference is not a footnote. It is the reason ad tech keeps hiring for pitch skills when it should be hiring for auditors who enjoy being disliked.

A team of 250, by his count

Matthew’s biggest job at FreeWheel was building its team inside the Comcast India Engineering Center. It was a framework, not a hiring spree: talent acquisition, reporting, performance management, hiring local managers. The teams covered software development, test engineering, engineering operations and support, plus what he calls repeatable operations work that nobody puts on a conference panel.

The hard part was not the code. Offices that speak the same language still carry different assumptions about what words mean.

His example is the one every global manager learns the expensive way: whether something is a vague aspiration, a promise or a directive to do something next varies widely. A yes in one office is a commitment. In another, it means “I heard you,” which is the corporate equivalent of a dog nodding at a sandwich. Any manager who has ever tried to run a standup across three time zones knows the feeling. You do not hear a missed deadline. You hear a dozen different definitions of the word “soon.”

He also has a view about where the next Chennai is. Central Asia and the Caucasus. He points to what he calls huge numbers of very good tech graduates, and to hiring competition that is far less brutal than in India’s top cities or the western half of Eastern Europe. If you are an ad tech CFO reading this, that is not a tip. That is a memo, and the memo is addressed to your head of talent acquisition, who is already taking a nap.

Incremental: ROAS tells you what sold. Incrementality tells you what your ads caused.

Homeless in Reading

The origin story is not noble, he insists. “I moved to Reading. There was a job waiting for me, and then there wasn’t a job waiting for me.” He spent a lot of time sofa surfing, and it took years to get on track. There is no inspirational montage here, no cold open with a violin. There is a young man on somebody else’s couch, doing the math on the bus fare.

The first reliable job was business-to-business telemarketing, contract work for big tech names he remembers as Oracle and Microsoft. The job was phoning database administrators and IT directors and asking them a lot of impertinent questions about how their IT was set up. In other words, the first real ad tech training he ever got was calling strangers and asking them how their plumbing worked. Which, now that I think about it, is the whole industry’s origin story.

What it taught him: how enterprise technology works, who does what, and confidence. “I learned to just speak to people.” Anyone who has sat through an ad tech sales call that opens with “we’re disrupting the disruptors” will appreciate how rare that skill has become.

His mother, he says, did not leave the country between roughly 1974 and 2010. His father left school at fourteen. His grandparents were manual laborers. So yes, he still wakes up surprised, and he still can’t believe his life went this direction without anyone printing the map.

He has a line for every new starter who doubts themselves: “I am a very, very ordinary guy with no great education, no great background. I’ve just managed to master it. And if I can do it, you can do it.”

You can hear him say it. The Reading story, the telemarketing years and the Mastermind confession are all in the full episode on YouTube.

Keep reading free with your email: how Ayn Rand lost a quiz show to Eurovision, the boss who taught him to always answer “yes,” why tech skills are the easy part, and the Brassed Off story that answers whether ad tech matters.

Ayn Rand lost to Eurovision

Matthew has been on UK national television twice: University Challenge and Mastermind. For Americans, think Jeopardy, minus the fun and plus a spotlight that could double as an interrogation lamp. “Mastermind is a quiz program of intense seriousness. You put in this big black leather chair and a spotlight is shone on you.”

How did he do? “I lost.”

His specialist subject, at twenty-four: the life and works of Ayn Rand. He lost to a man whose specialist subject was Eurovision. “I think this is an object lesson about choosing your subjects. I chose the subject of a famously prolix writer.”

For the record, he has read Atlas Shrugged multiple times, The Fountainhead, Anthem and a good deal more. Is he a follower? “No is the answer. It’s an academic interest rather than devoutness.”

I told him every sixteen-year-old reads Rand, decides she is amazing, and then looks at you like you are lying when you say she ended up on Social Security. He confirmed it. “She did.” Which is the most satisfying one-word answer I have gotten from a guest since a man on this show told me his trading desk ran on sticky notes.

Here is the thing about being beaten by Eurovision. It is not humiliating in the way you think. It is humiliating in the way that teaches you something. Matthew’s own lesson is about choosing your subject: he picked the writer who never used one word where forty would do, and the other man picked a song contest. He said so on air, without excuses, which is more than most ad tech founders do after a bad quarter.

The man who builds wells

Matthew’s Yoda is Nigel Linacre, and he is, in Matthew’s words, “very much the opposite of Ayn Rand. He is a man who has spent his entire life living for other people.” Matthew says Linacre was awarded the British Empire Medal for fundraising to build wells in Africa.

Linacre spent a couple of decades as an advertising executive, which is the first thing that should make every reader of this newsletter sit up. Then he co-founded a water charity, WellBoring, which builds school wells in East Africa. Matthew credits him with safe water for 700,000 people. Linacre has also written an opera about grief after the death of his son, and started work on a new psychological framework for understanding it. The man has done more with a single life than most agencies have done with their entire decks.

And still, Matthew says, “he is driven by the desire to have done more with his life.”

Does that make advertising feel small? Matthew didn’t flinch. “The fundamental reality, beyond anything else, is that you are going to die. You have a finite number of heartbeats.”

I said, “And that’s the show.” It wasn’t. But it was a good line, and I’m keeping it.

The Linacre story also works as a corrective to the industry’s favorite self-image, which is that we are all doing something important. Matthew does not say that. He says the important part is what you do with the time you have. Ad tech, in that frame, is a job. It can be a good job. It is not a calling, and the people who insist it is tend to be the ones who sell the calling in a deck.

“Have you done this yet?”

His first real boss, Joe Ryle, was COO of a start-up Matthew joined in his early twenties. Matthew describes Ryle as younger than Matthew is now, and crotchety with it. Ryle had spent much of his twenties and thirties bumming around North Africa, the Middle East and Turkey, then came home and got big in managed service providers.

Matthew calls him “a nightmare to work for” and also says he is in the party of the angels. Good isn’t always nice. Ask any ad tech sales team that has been on the receiving end of a quarterly review.

Ryle’s management style was a single question, asked first thing every morning: “Have you done this yet?”

Matthew’s response was pure spite. “I beat him by always having the answer be yes.” He took over support, then built the company’s office in Ukraine, mostly, he admits, to win that argument. That is what peak petty looks like in a Comcast-adjacent career, and I respect it enormously.

What stuck: Ryle hated corporate nonsense and always asked one thing. “What is the problem you are trying to solve?”

If every ad tech vendor had to answer that question before pitching a new “AI-powered attention layer,” half the category would evaporate by lunch. The other half would have to explain what their product does without the word “ecosystem,” which would be a lot harder to say on a sales call than you’d think.

Tech is the easy part

Matt Egol told us culture and change management matter more than technology. Matthew goes further. The only knowledge that matters, he says, is how to be a person.

He has watched it with new graduates in India, brilliant and hungry and always starting with the tech. “Often the solutions they have are great, but they’re not solutions to real problems people have.” That, friends, is a description of roughly every martech stack ever sold. Somebody built a beautiful machine, then went looking for a problem to justify it.

His view of technical skill is almost insulting. “Tech skills are actually fairly easy.” In the old days you pasted the error message into Stack Exchange and did what the top answer said. “That’s what Claude is doing now. It’s looking up Stack Exchange from fifteen years ago.” Which is a sentence I expect to see quoted back at me by someone at a conference who has never once read a Stack Exchange answer.

The hard part is learning to sublimate your baser instincts, to be wise and careful, to treat people properly and to master your emotions. That, he says, is much harder and much more important. I’d add one more item for the ad tech syllabus: learning to say “I don’t know” in a meeting without reaching for a deck.

Does ad tech matter?

He answered with a movie. Brassed Off, about a colliery brass band whose members have all been laid off from the mine. Matthew says the story is set where he comes from, Sheffield. The band leader focuses on winning a competition, wins it, and realizes the point was the people all along, which Matthew describes as a very British underdog ending. Hollywood would have paid for a more explosive finale. The British just gave everyone a tuba and a long walk home.

Matthew says the film’s speech opens Chumbawamba’s “Tubthumping.” He is right, with an asterisk: it opens the album version, not the radio edit the rest of us know. The idea he took from it is the one that matters: the music is less important than the people playing it.

So ad tech? Matthew volunteers with Zero Strays Georgia, which moves stray dogs from Georgia to Western Europe, and he sometimes packs lorries of humanitarian aid for Ukraine. “I’m not removing land mines, and I’m not doing heart surgery, but I’m doing what I can with what I’ve got.” Which is the most honest answer to “is your job meaningful” I have heard from anyone who sells programmatic inventory for a living.

Then the best moment in the episode. When he left Comcast, someone he had hired in India sent him a message: “You advocated for my hiring. And you will never know how much you have changed the trajectory of me and my family.”

“Then at least it’s been worth something.”

I have interviewed a lot of people who sell software. I have not interviewed many who could tell me the name of the person they hired who changed their life. Matthew can. That is the ad tech story I would like to read more often.

Rapid fire

  • Doctor Who or Red Dwarf: Red Dwarf. “It’s very aware that it’s stupid, and it’s engagingly stupid.” Doctor Who, he says, is fifty minutes of difficulty followed by a sonic screwdriver in minute fifty-five. I have no defense for Doctor Who. I have tried.

  • Best flavour: tamarind Jarritos. He spotted the bottle on my desk. We agreed. Tamil food, he notes, is full of tamarind, and he is not wrong.

  • Superpower: speaking every language. Across his seven: “I can usually ask for a beer.” Languages, he says, are about humility and respect. He is a man who has learned to say “thank you” in five languages and has become beloved in all of them.

  • One piece of life advice: from Star Trek: The Next Generation, “The Inner Light.” “Seize the day. Live now. Now will never come again.”

I also got him to agree that Star Trek is the one with the lightsabers. He agreed with me. He is a generous man, and a terrible Trekkie.

This issue is based on Pesach Lattin’s ADOTAT Show interview with Matthew Wolff Simon, recorded June 22, 2026, when Matthew was still at FreeWheel. Quotes are lightly edited from the recording for readability. Figures Matthew cited from memory were checked against public sources where possible, and the 700,000 figure is his. Matthew’s current title was confirmed with him by email before publication. The ADOTAT Show is sponsored by Troutman Amin LLP and Incremental, which have no say over guests, questions or edits. ADOTAT uses AI tools, including Anthropic’s Claude, in its production. ADOTAT is reader-supported. No paid placement in editorial.

Behind the paywall

  1. Checking the claims. How old ad tech really is, the RTB date, the FreeWheel accreditation, the Copernican math, and the title I got wrong on air.

  2. Where Matthew is wrong. Agents don’t kill the middlemen. They give them a new invoice and a better slide deck.

  3. What a buyer should ask. Four questions for the next vendor who wants your budget, and what a bad answer sounds like.

  4. The Brassed Off receipts. We went looking for the speech Matthew quoted. He was right, and almost nobody has heard it.

Above the wall is the conversation. Below it are the receipts.

ADOTAT+ is where the receipts live. Every claim checked against the record, the argument I did not make on air, and the investigations no vendor in this industry will ever sponsor. Join ADOTAT+ and read the rest. Reader-funded, which is the only reason any of it gets published.

logo

You've read this far. Read the rest with us.

Members fund the reporting and read it first. No advertisers, no sponsored anything, just the people who want this work to exist.

Join ADOTAT+

What members get:

  • Every investigation, including the ones with a lawyer's fingerprints on them. Those are the good ones.
  • The Field Kit. Because "do your own diligence" is useless advice without the actual checklist.
  • Their side, unedited. You get the full statement before I take it apart. Judge for yourself which of us is being unfair.
  • No paid editorial. Not one word, not ever. If it's in the copy, nobody paid to put it there.