This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsor: Troutman Amin LLP, Deserve to Win.

I asked the co-founder of the most decorated AI shop in advertising what he would like to be remembered for. He said his beard. By then he had already told me the real answer, and it was not nearly as funny.

Monks, the company formerly known as MediaMonks, had just been named Adweek's first ever AI Agency of the Year when I sat down with Wesley ter Haar, who co-founded it more than two decades ago, back when he was the Flash guy.

You know how that interview usually goes. The executive says AI is a copilot. The executive says it frees his people for higher-value work. The executive says nobody is losing a job, and then a quarter later somebody loses a job.

Ter Haar did not do that interview.

I asked whether we are building tools that elevate creativity or paving the road for our robot overlords. His answer started with the approved word and then kept going.

“Elevate, currently. But I do think we are building collectively, although a few companies own that, tools that can do a lot of what we as humans now see as our job.”

And on the timeline: “If you project outward, five, ten years, maybe a little sooner, I think we'll see that it also does some of the work that we now so enjoy.”

Then I asked for the biggest risk of AI, in general, not just for agencies. He waved off the killer-robot scenarios as “a little too sci-fi.” What he is actually worried about is duller and much closer.

“I think the biggest risk is a relatively small but meaningful degradation of employment. I think modern economies get into real problems when you start hitting like eight or nine or ten percent unemployment. And I think that might be a possibility, where it happens just in every type of role, every type of company, a little bit, and a little bit more every year, without the new jobs becoming available in the right timeline.”

Read that again and remember who is saying it. Not a union. Not a professor. The man whose company just won the trophy for doing this better than anyone else.

His version of optimism was this: “Pretty much every client wants people in the loop still. So there's hope for us yet.”

Hope for us yet. From the winner.

The poetry test

Somewhere in the middle of the ethics talk I tried to sneak a clause into our hypothetical global AI playbook: no AI-written poetry. Ter Haar had bad news for me, and it came with a citation.

He brought up research he had seen, a blind taste test putting AI-written poetry against some of the great works. “Most people preferred the AI written poetry. So it's a bit of a depressing thought about what people actually see as good versus not so good.”

Sit with that one for a second, because it is the quiet center of the whole AI-and-creativity debate. The threat to craft was never that the machine would out-write the masters. It is that the audience might not be able to tell, and might not care. Advertising has run on that unspoken suspicion for a century. The machine just made it measurable.

His favorite thing about the models, for what it is worth, is when they refuse him. “I love it the most when the models don't want to do something. You're like, nice.” I pointed out they will also tell you they did the thing when they did not, and argue about it afterward. We agreed this is the most human feature the technology has.

“We've done worse”

I asked whether there was a moment in the past year when he felt excitement and anxiety about AI in the same breath. There was, and he remembered it precisely.

It was a demo built on one of the GPT-4 era models. Someone had prompted their way through building an entire product in about eight minutes.

“And you were looking at it going, we've done worse. That's actually pretty strong.”

That is a founder of a global production company watching a stranger with a text box and concluding that the output clears a bar his own teams have, on occasion, failed to clear. He drew the obvious conclusion: “It's not that difficult to see how quickly parts of the ecosystem are going to get disrupted.”

The only brake he named is inertia. Monks works for enormous global companies, and, as he put it, the enterprise is sticky. Behavior there does not change as fast as it could or should. That is not a moat. That is a delay.

He also told me this pivot will be the hardest of the five or so the company has made. Harder than 2007 or 2008, when Monks stopped being a digital agency and became a production company, a move that required it to “fire all of our clients” and was, he admits, “more gut feeling than strategy.”

Subscribe to keep reading

This content won’t cost you a dime, but here’s the catch: you need to be subscribed to ADOTAT – your front-row seat to everything Adtech, Marketing, and Media – to keep the good stuff coming.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now