This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsor: Troutman Amin LLP, Deserve to Win.

Zach Rozga showed up to this recording wearing a mustache he grew for Halloween and, by his own admission, partly dyed. He confessed to the dye before I asked. It set the tone for the next forty minutes.

Thece is one of those company names that sounds like a typo until the founder explains it. It stands for The Consumer Engagement Company, and Rozga, its CEO, says that phrase is the overriding driver of everything they do. His pitch, in his words: “actual human engagement, not just robots pushing messages to other robots.”

I have heard a lot of founders promise to bring humanity back to advertising. Most of them are selling a dashboard. Rozga is selling something stranger and, I think, more interesting: video game challenges with a brand's name on the door.

The product is called ThecePlay. He describes it as pop-up tournaments, quests and challenges. “Think of like a MrBeast challenge,” he told me, except instead of one creator picking a winner, Thece says it has “a transparent and scalable solution that actually allows every one of his audience members to participate and actually identify the true and accurate winner.”

And then the line that every media buyer on earth wants to hear.

“The way our system is set up, there's no skip button.”

Here is how he gets there. Most advertising in games, he argues, is an interruption. A skippable ad in a mobile game. A non-skippable interstitial. A rewarded video. On console, a branded Fortnite map that “effectively makes you go away from what you do with your friends and go to some map that you've never heard of before.” Same with Roblox, he says: “you're basically interrupting the audience and telling them to do something new.”

Thece's version asks for none of that. “Let's just say it's FIFA. The only thing we ask you to do is play your favorite game with your friends, record it, and show us that you kicked their ass. And once you did, I'm going to reward you for that.”

No interruption. No skip button. You were going to play anyway.

It is a clean idea. It is also, and this is where Rozga earned my respect, five campaigns old.

“Look, we're early. I'm going to be very honest. We're still in our sort of pilot phase. We've run five of these now. It's not like this thing's at scale and everybody knows about it.”

So that is the story. A founder with a sharp diagnosis of what is wrong with programmatic, a cure he believes in, and a sample size of five. Both halves are worth your time. Just keep them in separate columns.

The report card: a D-plus, and only because the F was retired

I asked him what grade Gen Z would give marketers. He split the question, which was smart.

Marketers in general: “probably like a C.”

Programmatic: “a big fat D-plus merging on an F.”

Why not the F? “Where my kids go to school, we don't have F anymore.” So programmatic passes on a technicality involving his children's report cards. I have seen worse methodology in a measurement deck.

His actual reasoning is less funny and more uncomfortable. He does not think Gen Z hates your programmatic ad. He thinks they never see it.

“They either don't go on browsers. They don't exist in browsers. I've even been told, ‘you know what, your dot com website doesn't really exist. It needs to live in a Discord.’ They all have ad blockers. They don't watch TV. So you can't get them on CTV. That's why I'd give them a D-plus, because they don't actually see it very often. They're really good at just avoiding it.”

Then he went after the machine itself.

“Personally, I feel like we've gotten to peak programmatic, and a lot of that was really stripping creativity out for efficiency.”

And: “When you're looking at programmatic, which commands 60 to 70 percent of budgets, there's no creativity there. It's just reach, frequency and efficiency.”

That budget figure is his, offered from memory in conversation, and I am passing it along as his estimate and nothing firmer. The fraud point he made is harder to wave off, because the industry's own research has been making it for two years: “A lot of the traffic is actually not real traffic. It's showing up on made for advertising pages. There's bot armies out there that are doing clicks.”

He admits to “somewhat of an allergic reaction to programmatic.” Fine. A man is allowed his allergies. What I would point out is that the allergy is also the business plan. Every dollar Thece wants is a dollar currently sitting in a reach-and-frequency line item. When the guy selling the alternative grades the incumbent, read the grade and then check who owns the red pen.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content won’t cost you a dime, but here’s the catch: you need to be subscribed to ADOTAT – your front-row seat to everything Adtech, Marketing, and Media – to keep the good stuff coming.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now