This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsor: Troutman Amin LLP, Deserve to Win.

David Kohl spent years as the consultant NBC and Disney called when programmatic started eating their lunch. Then he built a company on the premise that the open web was being sold by the pound. He came on the week MFA hit the front page, and he did not soften anything.

David Kohl runs TrustX, a programmatic marketplace built to sell premium publishers as premium instead of lumping them in with everything else. Before that he advised NBC, Disney, GroupM, IPG and others at PwC and EY. His origin story starts with a line from Jeff Zucker around 2008 about trading analog dollars for digital pennies, and his clients watching it happen in real time.

What he heard from those clients, across every part of the supply chain, was the same complaint in different accents:

“All that promise that automation is gonna bring efficiency, automation is gonna make it better one-to-one. Come on, it's all bullshit. Like we created an ecosystem that was designed to create profit in the middle, and we failed to remember that our job was to enable brands to get to their consumer at the right place at the right time.”

He credited the cleanest version of the diagnosis to someone else: where there's mystery, there's margin.

“There is zero possibility”

The episode was recorded the week made-for-advertising sites were back in the trade headlines. Kohl did not hedge.

“There is zero possibility that an advertiser will truly get value from MFA, period. There are ways that MFA can game the system with attribution pixels. It's like fraud.”

He went back to the bot-fraud era for the comparison, when people argued that some fraud works. “Fraud does not work. Fraud is not a person. Fraud cannot buy your product. So MFA is the same thing.” If a brand thinks the cheap inventory is performing, he says, the most likely explanation is that the attribution is being played: “It's because the MFA publisher has gamed the attribution system to look like they're delivering you a return on investment. It's not real.”

The waste is only half of it. He cited research that, in his recollection, put something like 60 to 70 percent of consumers saying they would stop buying from a brand they saw on one of these clickbait sites. He admitted he was going from memory on the number. The point stands either way: the brand is not just losing money, it is being seen in a place its own customers hold against it.

He has been on the receiving end. He is a private pilot, and the clickbait engines figured that out. “They're really good at putting clickbait for airplanes that looks like it's real legit stuff. And then I'm sucked down the MFA vortex like you.”

Don't outsource it

Here is the line that should make every verification sales deck uncomfortable.

“Don't outsource MFA to IAS and DV. Don't outsource it.”

He was careful to say the vendors and list-makers have a role. He named Jounce Media and Chris Kane with affection and called those lists “starting points.” But a starting point is not a strategy. “Don't be asleep at the switch. Don't be like, I outsource it to somebody else and then whatever they say goes. That's not a sustainable approach for quality long-tail media and it's also probably not good for you as an advertiser.”

His alternative is so simple it sounds naive until you notice almost nobody does it. Start with an inclusion list. Every brand already has reports showing which publishers drive results. “If they don't, you're asleep at the switch or your agency's asleep at the switch. I guarantee you quality brands know what works for them.”

He told a story from the Cannes beach with Lou Paskalis, who pointed at the sand and said chasing MFA was like counting the grains. Kohl's version: “As quickly as you think you've excluded something, a new one pops up. As quickly as you've got a filter, someone else is passing the filter. And by the way, as quickly as we create a standard, the MFAs will game that standard.”

His math for the fix: 50 to 100 sellers on a list will cover every person a brand wants to reach. Forgot someone? “Add them later. That's okay. You can change your list over time.”

Subscribe to keep reading

This content won’t cost you a dime, but here’s the catch: you need to be subscribed to ADOTAT – your front-row seat to everything Adtech, Marketing, and Media – to keep the good stuff coming.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now