This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Sponsor: Troutman Amin LLP, Deserve to Win.

Jeff Hirsch says he has been doing ad tech since 1996 and is just about ready to get it figured out. Along the way he worked at nearly every Santa Barbara company with "click" in the name, and he remembers what the early business actually ran on.

Jeff Hirsch has had three careers: print, radio and agency advertising; eight years running a software company; and then the internet. In 1996 he wrote a business plan for an early ad network he called AdClick. He could not raise money for it, but he used it to walk into ValueClick in Santa Barbara, where he happened to live. From there: FastClick, Audience Science, PubMatic as CMO and then chief commercial officer through its IPO, and at the time of the recording, Aperiam, working with Joe Zawadzki.

Twenty cents in, fifty cents out

His description of the early ad network business is a good reminder of where programmatic came from.

“We had stacks of books with website names and owners and they were just calling up saying, did you know you can make money by running ads on your site? And they had no clue. And then we were offering them 19, 20, 21 cents a click.”

ValueClick and its rival, then called TechnoSurf, bid against each other for the supply, and then the network turned around and sold it “at 50 cents plus on the CPC side.”

He was honest about what a lot of that money bought. “It was really to drive traffic to websites to support their efforts to go public.” Traffic, not conversions. “There's no long-term value there.” And the industry believed click-through rate would be the measure forever.

The crash that invented a model

FastClick was started by aerospace engineers out of UC Santa Barbara who looked at ValueClick and decided they could do it faster. Then the market crashed before they got going. “By the time we got to market, the market had crashed. So CPC was not going to be an effective model.”

The fix came from co-founder Jeff Pryor's algorithms, which took an advertiser's cost-per-acquisition deal and converted it automatically into an effective CPM the company could confidently pay publishers. Advertisers paid for performance. Publishers got a CPM. “Overcoming it actually gave us the magic to build a company that eventually also went public.”

He also put a date on a format everyone uses without thinking about. They started with 468 banners, added 728s, “and then we came up with the brilliant idea to do medium rectangles.” The big money of that era, he said, was pop-unders.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content won’t cost you a dime, but here’s the catch: you need to be subscribed to ADOTAT – your front-row seat to everything Adtech, Marketing, and Media – to keep the good stuff coming.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now